Fleming Jennifer C, Bao Feng, Chen Yuhua, Hamilton Eilis F, Gonzalez-Lara Laura E, Foster Paula J, Weaver Lynne C
Spinal Cord Injury Laboratory, The University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, Canada.
J Neurosurg Spine. 2009 Nov;11(5):575-87. doi: 10.3171/2009.6.SPINE08915.
After spinal cord injury (SCI) leukocytes infiltrate the injured cord, causing significant damage and further impairment of functional recovery. The leukocyte integrin alpha4beta1 is crucial for their entry. The authors previously demonstrated that an anti-alpha4 monoclonal antibody (mAb) treatment attenuates leukocyte infiltration, improves motor and autonomic function, and reduces neuropathic pain when administered at 2 hours and 24 hours after SCI.
The authors conducted 2 preclinical studies: the first determined effects of treatment commencing at 6 hours, a clinically relevant time after injury, and the second examined effects of long-lasting treatment (28 days) on neurological recovery after SCI, as current clinically used anti-inflammatory monoclonal antibodies have such longevity. In the first study (timing study), rats were treated with anti-alpha4 or control mAb (intravenously) at 6 hours and 48 hours after moderate (35 g) thoracic compression SCI. Effects on intraspinal inflammation and oxidative injury were assessed at 3 and 7 days after SCI; motor function and pain were examined for 6 weeks. In the second study (duration study), anti-alpha4 mAb was administered starting 2 hours after SCI and subsequently every 3 days for 4 weeks (total of 8 doses), using a schedule of decreasing doses to resemble the pharmacodynamics of long-lasting antibodies used clinically. Motor function and pain were examined for 6 weeks. Lesions were assessed for tissue sparing and inflammation at 6 weeks by histological examination and MR imaging.
Anti-alpha4 mAb treatment at 6 hours and 48 hours after SCI (timing study) significantly decreased neutrophil and monocyte/macrophage influx at 3 days by 36% and 20%, respectively, but had no effect by at 7 days after SCI. Antibody treatment significantly reduced intraspinal myeloperoxidase activity by 48% and lipid peroxidation by 27% at 3 days post-injury. The treatment did not improve locomotor function but reduced mechanical allodynia elicited from the trunk and hind paw by ~50% at 3-6 weeks after SCI. In contrast, long-term mAb treatment commencing at 2 hours after SCI (duration study) significantly improved locomotor function at 2-6 weeks after SCI, (mean BBB scores +/- SE: treated rats, 8.3 +/- 0.16; controls, 7.3 +/- 0.2 at 6 weeks). At 3-6 weeks, mAb treatment decreased mechanical allodynia elicited from the trunk and hind paw by ~55%. This recovery correlated with 30% more myelin-containing white matter in treated rats than controls at 6 weeks. The lesion cavity was smaller in the treated rats when assessed by both histological (-37%) and imaging (-50%) methods. The accumulation of ED1-immunoreactive microglia/macrophages at the lesion was similar in treated and control rats.
Although delayed treatment reduced intraspinal inflammation and pain, motor function was not improved, revealing decreased efficacy at the more clinically feasibly treatment onset. Long-term anti-alpha4 mAb treatment starting 2 hours after SCI improved neurological outcomes, with tissue sparing near the lesion and no impairment of the late immune response to injury. These findings reveal no disadvantage of long-lasting immunosuppression by the treatment but show that efficacy depends upon very early delivery.
脊髓损伤(SCI)后,白细胞浸润受损脊髓,造成严重损害并进一步阻碍功能恢复。白细胞整合素α4β1对其进入至关重要。作者先前证明,在脊髓损伤后2小时和24小时给予抗α4单克隆抗体(mAb)治疗可减轻白细胞浸润,改善运动和自主神经功能,并减轻神经性疼痛。
作者进行了两项临床前研究:第一项确定在损伤后6小时(一个与临床相关的时间点)开始治疗的效果,第二项研究了长期治疗(28天)对脊髓损伤后神经恢复的影响,因为目前临床使用的抗炎单克隆抗体具有这样的长效性。在第一项研究(时间研究)中,大鼠在中度(35克)胸段压迫性脊髓损伤后6小时和48小时接受抗α4或对照mAb(静脉注射)治疗。在脊髓损伤后3天和7天评估对脊髓内炎症和氧化损伤的影响;对运动功能和疼痛进行6周的检查。在第二项研究(持续时间研究)中,从脊髓损伤后2小时开始给予抗α4 mAb,随后每3天给药一次,共4周(共8剂),采用递减剂量方案以模拟临床使用的长效抗体的药效学。对运动功能和疼痛进行6周的检查。在6周时通过组织学检查和磁共振成像评估损伤部位的组织保留和炎症情况。
在脊髓损伤后6小时和48小时进行抗α4 mAb治疗(时间研究),在3天时中性粒细胞和单核细胞/巨噬细胞的浸润分别显著减少36%和20%,但在脊髓损伤后7天时无效果。抗体治疗在损伤后3天时使脊髓内髓过氧化物酶活性显著降低48%,脂质过氧化降低27%。该治疗未改善运动功能,但在脊髓损伤后3至6周使躯干和后爪引起的机械性异常性疼痛降低约50%。相比之下,在脊髓损伤后2小时开始的长期mAb治疗(持续时间研究)在脊髓损伤后2至6周显著改善了运动功能(平均BBB评分±标准误:治疗组大鼠在6周时为8.3±0.16;对照组为7.3±0.2)。在3至6周时,mAb治疗使躯干和后爪引起的机械性异常性疼痛降低约55%。这种恢复与治疗组大鼠在6周时比对照组多30%的含髓鞘白质相关。通过组织学(-37%)和成像(-50%)方法评估时,治疗组大鼠的损伤腔较小。治疗组和对照组大鼠在损伤部位ED1免疫反应性小胶质细胞/巨噬细胞的积聚相似。
尽管延迟治疗可减轻脊髓内炎症和疼痛,但运动功能未改善,这表明在更符合临床实际的治疗开始时间点疗效降低。在脊髓损伤后2小时开始的长期抗α4 mAb治疗改善了神经学结果,损伤部位附近有组织保留,且对损伤的晚期免疫反应无损害。这些发现表明该治疗的长期免疫抑制无不利影响,但显示疗效取决于非常早期的给药。