Ma Jun, Berra Kathy, Haskell William L, Klieman Linda, Hyde Shauna, Smith Mark W, Xiao Lan, Stafford Randall S
Palo Alto Medical Foundation Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA, USA.
Arch Intern Med. 2009 Nov 23;169(21):1988-95. doi: 10.1001/archinternmed.2009.381.
Case management (CM) is a systematic approach to supplement physician-centered efforts to prevent cardiovascular disease (CVD). Research is limited on its implementation and efficacy in low-income, ethnic minority populations.
We conducted a randomized clinical trial to evaluate a nurse- and dietitian-led CM program for reducing major CVD risk factors in low-income, primarily ethnic minority patients in a county health care system, 63.0% of whom had type 2 diabetes mellitus. The primary outcome was the Framingham risk score (FRS).
A total of 419 patients at elevated risk of CVD events were randomized and followed up for a mean of 16 months (81.4% retention). The mean FRS was significantly lower for the CM vs usual care group at follow-up (7.80 [95% confidence interval, 7.21-8.38] vs 8.93 [8.36-9.49]; P = .001) after adjusting for baseline FRS. This is equivalent to 5 fewer heart disease events per 1000 individuals per year attributable to the intervention or to 200 individuals receiving the intervention to prevent 1 event per year. The pattern of group differences in the FRS was similar in subgroups defined a priori by sex and ethnicity. The main driver of these differences was lowering the mean (SD) systolic (-4.2 [18.5] vs 2.6 [22.7] mm Hg; P = .003) and diastolic (-6.0 [11.6] vs -3.0 [11.7] mm Hg; P = .02) blood pressures for the CM vs usual care group.
Nurse and dietitian CM targeting multifactor risk reduction can lead to modest improvements in CVD risk factors among high-risk patients in low-income, ethnic minority populations receiving care in county health clinics.
clinicaltrials.gov Identifier: NCT00128687.
病例管理(CM)是一种系统性方法,用以补充以医生为中心预防心血管疾病(CVD)的工作。关于其在低收入少数族裔人群中的实施情况和疗效的研究有限。
我们开展了一项随机临床试验,以评估由护士和营养师主导的CM项目,该项目旨在降低一个县医疗系统中低收入的主要为少数族裔患者的主要CVD危险因素,其中63.0%的患者患有2型糖尿病。主要结局是弗雷明汉风险评分(FRS)。
共有419名CVD事件风险升高的患者被随机分组,并平均随访了16个月(保留率81.4%)。在根据基线FRS进行调整后,随访时CM组的平均FRS显著低于常规护理组(7.80[95%置信区间,7.21 - 8.38]对8.93[8.36 - 9.49];P = 0.001)。这相当于该干预措施使每1000人每年的心脏病事件减少5例,或使200名接受干预的个体每年预防1例事件。在按性别和种族预先定义的亚组中,FRS的组间差异模式相似。这些差异的主要驱动因素是CM组与常规护理组相比,收缩压均值(标准差)降低(-4.2[18.5]对2.6[22.7]mmHg;P = 0.003),舒张压均值(标准差)降低(-6.0[11.6]对-3.0[11.7]mmHg;P = 0.02)。
针对多因素风险降低的护士和营养师CM可使在县卫生诊所接受治疗的低收入少数族裔高危患者的CVD危险因素得到适度改善。
clinicaltrials.gov标识符:NCT00128687。