Gregory Marilyn J, Milroy Christopher M
Department of Sociological Studies, University of Sheffield, Elmfield, Northumberland Rd, Sheffield, S10 2TU, United Kingdom.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 2010 Mar;31(1):58-63. doi: 10.1097/PAF.0b013e3181c2172a.
Homicide-suicide (HS) events in Yorkshire and the Humber have been documented previously by Milroy in a study of the period 1975 to 1992 (Milroy, Med Sci Law. 1993;33:167-171; Milroy 1994; Milroy, Forensic Sci Int. 1995;71:117-122; Milroy, Med Sci Law. 1995;35:213-217; and Milroy, J Clin Forensic Med. 1998;5:61-64). Reported here is an update of that study covering HS events in the same region from 1993 to 2007. Data from cohort 1 (1975-1992) and cohort 2 (1993-2007) are presented and compared, where data are available, with the findings of 2 previous studies in England and Wales (Barraclough and Harris, Psychol Med. 2002;32:577-584; and West 1965). Homicide followed by suicide is often defined in the literature as homicide(s) followed by the suicide of the perpetrator within 1 week of the homicide(s) (Barraclough and Harris, Psychol Med. 2002;32:577-584; Campanelli and Gilson, Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 2002;23:248-251; and Hannah et al, 1998;19:275-283). All the cases reported here fall within this definition. Findings are consonant with international literature, and suggest that HS is most likely to be carried out by an older, white, married, or cohabiting working man, who kills his female partner and/or their children and then himself. There are indications that restricting access to significant methods of killing can reduce the incidence of HS.
米尔罗伊曾在一项关于1975年至1992年期间的研究中记录了约克郡和亨伯赛德郡的他杀后自杀(HS)事件(米尔罗伊,《医学与法律科学》。1993年;33:167 - 171;米尔罗伊,1994年;米尔罗伊,《法医学国际》。1995年;71:117 - 122;米尔罗伊,《医学与法律科学》。1995年;35:213 - 217;以及米尔罗伊,《临床法医学杂志》。1998年;5:61 - 64)。本文报告的是该研究的更新内容,涵盖了1993年至2007年同一地区的HS事件。呈现并比较了队列研究1(1975 - 1992年)和队列研究2(1993 - 2007年)的数据,在数据可得的情况下,还与英格兰和威尔士之前两项研究的结果进行了比较(巴拉克拉夫和哈里斯,《心理医学》。2002年;32:577 - 584;以及韦斯特,1965年)。在文献中,他杀后自杀通常被定义为在他杀发生后的1周内犯罪者自杀(巴拉克拉夫和哈里斯,《心理医学》。2002年;32:577 - 584;坎帕内利和吉尔森,《美国法医病理学杂志》。2002年;23:248 - 251;以及汉娜等人,1998年;19:275 - 283)。这里报告的所有案例都符合这一定义。研究结果与国际文献一致,表明HS最有可能由一名年龄较大、白人、已婚或同居的在职男性实施,他先杀死自己的女性伴侣和/或他们的孩子,然后自杀。有迹象表明,限制获取重要的杀人手段可以降低HS的发生率。