Petrova Gergana G, Popov Teodor N
Department of Healthcare Management, Medical University, Plovdiv, Bulgaria.
Folia Med (Plovdiv). 2009 Jul-Sep;51(3):60-6.
Organisation and management are factors of paramount importance in higher education for achieving higher quality of training, better professional adaptation, and more effective career pursuance of the students.
The present study analyses the use of various teaching methods for the students in the major of Healthcare Management as they are employed in two medical universities.
We conducted a detailed questionnaire survey which included the students in the Healthcare Management major in the Faculty of Public Health (FPH) at Sofia Medical University (SMU) and the Medical Faculty of Plovdiv Medical University (PMU). The students were surveyed for two consecutive academic years (2004/2005 and 2005/2006). The logical units of study were 198 students completing their baccalaureate programs in Healthcare Management: 145 (73.23+/-3.15%) in the FPH, SMU and 53 (26.77+/-3.15%) in the PMU (the greater number of students from the SMU was due to the greater number of students admitted into the Sofia Medical University). The technical units of study were the Faculty of Public Health in the Medical University in Sofia and the Medical faculty in the Medical University in Plovdiv. The survey was carried out using our own questionnaire form comprising 51 questions (open and closed), some of them allowing more than one answer. The collected sociological data were analysed using SPSS v. 13.0, and the diagrams were made using Microsoft Excel' 97. We used the alternative, non-parametric and graphic analyses to illustrate the processes and events at a level of significance P < 0.05.
The most frequently used teaching method in both Medical Universities is the lecture (30.43+/-3.63% for PMU and 26.32+/-1.91% for SMU). This format of teaching is also considered to be the easiest with regard to learning the study material by 22.75+/-3.25% of the PMU graduates and 27.56+/-2.38% of the SMU graduates. The PMU students regard seminars, individual work and discussions as the format that afford the easiest way to acquire knowledge (22.16+/-3.21%, 21.56+/-3.18%, (18.56+/-3.01%, respectively). The most frequently used teaching method is the lecture; for the SMU student, it is used in 91.67+/-5.64% of all cases, while for PMU it is 8.33+/-5.64%.
Students prefer the classical teaching methods. They are the most familiar and the most frequently used formats by lecturers, although they do not require a higher level of activity on the part of the students, who in T. Popov's view "...demonstrate passive attitude towards the educational process".
组织与管理是高等教育中极为重要的因素,对于实现更高质量的培训、更好的职业适应以及学生更有效的职业追求而言。
本研究分析了两所医科大学中用于卫生保健管理专业学生的各种教学方法的使用情况。
我们进行了一项详细的问卷调查,调查对象包括索非亚医科大学公共卫生学院(FPH)和普罗夫迪夫医科大学医学院卫生保健管理专业的学生。连续两个学年(2004/2005和2005/2006)对学生进行了调查。研究的逻辑单位是198名完成卫生保健管理学士学位课程的学生:索非亚医科大学公共卫生学院有145名(73.23+/-3.15%),普罗夫迪夫医科大学医学院有53名(26.77+/-3.15%)(索非亚医科大学学生人数较多是因为该校录取的学生数量更多)。研究的技术单位是索非亚医科大学的公共卫生学院和普罗夫迪夫医科大学的医学院。调查使用了我们自己设计的包含51个问题(开放式和封闭式)的问卷形式,其中一些问题允许多个答案。使用SPSS v. 13.0对收集到的社会学数据进行分析,使用Microsoft Excel' 97绘制图表。我们使用非参数替代分析和图形分析来阐释在显著性水平P < 0.05下的过程和事件。
两所医科大学最常使用的教学方法都是讲座(普罗夫迪夫医科大学为30.43+/-3.63%,索非亚医科大学为26.32+/-1.91%)。22.75+/-3.25%的普罗夫迪夫医科大学毕业生和27.56+/-2.38%的索非亚医科大学毕业生认为这种教学形式在学习学习材料方面也是最容易的。普罗夫迪夫医科大学的学生认为研讨会、个人作业和讨论是获取知识最便捷的形式(分别为22.16+/-3.21%、21.56+/-3.18%、18.56+/-3.01%)。最常使用的教学方法是讲座;对于索非亚医科大学的学生,在所有情况中使用比例为91.67+/-5.64%,而对于普罗夫迪夫医科大学则为8.33+/-5.64%。
学生更喜欢传统教学方法。它们是讲师最熟悉且最常使用的形式,尽管这些方法并不要求学生有更高的参与度,在T. 波波夫看来,学生“……对教育过程表现出消极态度”。