Department of Movement and Sport Sciences, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Int J Behav Nutr Phys Act. 2009 Dec 6;6:82. doi: 10.1186/1479-5868-6-82.
Although physical activity is considered to yield substantial health benefits, the level of physical activity among European teenagers is not sufficient. Adolescence is characterized by a decline in physical activity level. Many studies investigated the effectiveness of interventions promoting physical activity among young people, but none dealt with the available evidence specific for Europe. This review was conducted to summarize the effectiveness of interventions to promote physical activity among European teenagers.
A systematic review was conducted to identify European intervention studies published in the scientific literature since 1995. Four databases were searched, reference lists were scanned and the publication lists of the authors of the retrieved articles were checked. The ANGELO framework was used to categorise the included studies by setting and by intervention components.
The literature search identified 20 relevant studies. Fifteen interventions were delivered through the school setting, of which three included a family component and another three a family and community component. One intervention was conducted within a community setting, three were delivered in primary care and one was delivered through the internet. Ten interventions included only an individual component, whereas the other ten used a multi-component approach. None of the interventions included only an environmental component.Main findings of the review were: (1) school-based interventions generally lead to short term improvements in physical activity levels; (2) improvements in physical activity levels by school-based interventions were limited to school related physical activity with no conclusive transfer to leisure time physical activity; (3) including parents appeared to enhance school-based interventions; (4) the support of peers and the influence of direct environmental changes increased the physical activity level of secondary school children; (5) the assumption that a multi-component approach should produce synergistic results can not be confirmed; (6) when interventions aimed to affect more than one health behaviour the intervention appeared to be less effective in favour of physical activity.
Overall, the current European literature supports the short-term effectiveness of school-based physical activity promotion programmes. The available evidence for the effectiveness in other settings is rather limited and underscores the need for further research.
尽管身体活动被认为能带来显著的健康益处,但欧洲青少年的身体活动水平还不够。青少年时期的身体活动水平会下降。许多研究调查了促进年轻人身体活动的干预措施的有效性,但没有一项研究针对欧洲的具体情况。本综述旨在总结促进欧洲青少年身体活动的干预措施的有效性。
系统检索了自 1995 年以来在科学文献中发表的欧洲干预研究。检索了四个数据库,扫描了参考文献列表,并检查了检索文章作者的出版列表。使用 ANGELO 框架根据设置和干预组成部分对纳入的研究进行分类。
文献检索确定了 20 项相关研究。15 项干预措施通过学校环境实施,其中 3 项干预措施包括家庭组成部分,另外 3 项干预措施包括家庭和社区组成部分。1 项干预措施在社区环境中进行,3 项干预措施在初级保健中进行,1 项干预措施通过互联网进行。10 项干预措施仅包含个体组成部分,而其他 10 项干预措施采用了多组分方法。没有一项干预措施仅包含环境组成部分。本综述的主要发现是:(1)基于学校的干预措施通常会导致身体活动水平的短期提高;(2)基于学校的干预措施对身体活动水平的改善仅限于与学校相关的身体活动,没有确凿的证据表明这可以转移到闲暇时间的身体活动;(3)包括家长似乎可以增强基于学校的干预措施;(4)同伴的支持和直接环境变化的影响增加了中学生的身体活动水平;(5)多组分方法应该产生协同效应的假设无法得到证实;(6)当干预措施旨在影响多种健康行为时,干预措施对身体活动的效果会降低。
总的来说,目前的欧洲文献支持基于学校的身体活动促进计划的短期有效性。其他环境下的有效性证据相当有限,这突出表明需要进一步研究。