Lipshultz S E, Colan S D, Gelber R D, Perez-Atayde A R, Sallan S E, Sanders S P
Department of Cardiology, Children's Hospital, Boston, MA 02115.
N Engl J Med. 1991 Mar 21;324(12):808-15. doi: 10.1056/NEJM199103213241205.
Cardiotoxicity is a recognized complication of doxorubicin therapy, but the long-term effects of doxorubicin are not well documented. We therefore assessed the cardiac status of 115 children who had been treated for acute lymphoblastic leukemia with doxorubicin 1 to 15 years earlier in whom the disease was in continuous remission.
Eighteen patients received one dose of doxorubicin (45 mg per square meter of body-surface area), and 97 received multiple doses totaling 228 to 550 mg per square meter (median, 360). The median interval between the end of treatment and the cardiac evaluation was 6.4 years. Our evaluation consisted of a history, 24-hour ambulatory electrocardiographic recording, exercise testing, and echocardiography.
Fifty-seven percent of the patients had abnormalities of left ventricular afterload (measured as end-systolic wall stress) or contractility (measured as the stress-velocity index). The cumulative dose of doxorubicin was the most significant predictor of abnormal cardiac function (P less than 0.002). Seventeen percent of patients who received one dose of doxorubicin had slightly elevated age-adjusted afterload, and none had decreased contractility. In contrast, 65 percent of patients who received at least 228 mg of doxorubicin per square meter had increased afterload (59 percent of patients), decreased contractility (23 percent), or both. Increased afterload was due to reduced ventricular wall thickness, not to hypertension or ventricular dilatation. In multivariate analyses restricted to patients who received at least 228 mg of doxorubicin per square meter, the only significant predictive factors were a higher cumulative dose (P = 0.01), which predicted decreased contractility, and an age of less than four years at treatment (P = 0.003), which predicted increased afterload. Afterload increased progressively in 24 of 34 patients evaluated serially (71 percent). Reported symptoms correlated poorly with indexes of exercise tolerance or ventricular function. Eleven patients had congestive heart failure within one year of treatment with doxorubicin; five of them had recurrent heart failure 3.7 to 10.3 years after completing doxorubicin treatment, and two required heart transplantation. No patient had late heart failure as a new event.
Doxorubicin therapy in childhood impairs myocardial growth in a dose-related fashion and results in a progressive increase in left ventricular afterload sometimes accompanied by reduced contractility. We hypothesize that the loss of myocytes during doxorubicin therapy in childhood might result in inadequate left ventricular mass and clinically important heart disease in later years.
心脏毒性是阿霉素治疗公认的并发症,但阿霉素的长期影响尚无充分文献记载。因此,我们评估了115例1至15年前接受过阿霉素治疗急性淋巴细胞白血病且疾病持续缓解的儿童的心脏状况。
18例患者接受一剂阿霉素(45mg/m²体表面积),97例接受多剂,总量为228至550mg/m²(中位数为360)。治疗结束至心脏评估的中位间隔时间为6.4年。我们的评估包括病史、24小时动态心电图记录、运动试验和超声心动图检查。
57%的患者存在左心室后负荷(以收缩末期壁应力衡量)或收缩性(以应力-速度指数衡量)异常。阿霉素的累积剂量是心脏功能异常最显著的预测因素(P<0.002)。接受一剂阿霉素的患者中,17%的年龄校正后负荷略有升高,无一例收缩性降低。相比之下,每平方米接受至少228mg阿霉素的患者中,65%存在后负荷增加(59%的患者)、收缩性降低(23%)或两者皆有。后负荷增加是由于心室壁厚度减小,而非高血压或心室扩张。在仅针对每平方米接受至少228mg阿霉素的患者进行的多因素分析中,唯一显著的预测因素是累积剂量较高(P=0.01,预测收缩性降低)以及治疗时年龄小于4岁(P=0.003,预测后负荷增加)。在34例接受系列评估的患者中,24例(71%)后负荷逐渐增加。报告的症状与运动耐量或心室功能指标相关性较差。11例患者在接受阿霉素治疗后1年内发生充血性心力衰竭;其中5例在完成阿霉素治疗后3.7至10.3年出现复发性心力衰竭,2例需要心脏移植。无患者出现新的晚期心力衰竭事件。
儿童期阿霉素治疗以剂量相关方式损害心肌生长,导致左心室后负荷逐渐增加,有时伴有收缩性降低。我们推测儿童期阿霉素治疗期间心肌细胞的丢失可能导致左心室质量不足,并在晚年引发具有临床重要性的心脏病。