Ehrlich Robert
Interdisciplinary Studies Field Major, University of California, Berkeley, USA.
J Am Acad Psychoanal Dyn Psychiatry. 2009 Winter;37(4):605-25. doi: 10.1521/jaap.2009.37.4.605.
This paper explores what is perhaps the most important contribution of Harry Guntrip to psychoanalysis: namely his concept of the "regressed ego." In the course of his psychoanalytic work, he found certain concepts to be problematic. Therefore, while he valued some of Freud's ideas, he challenged his emphasis upon the importance of the instincts. Guntrip then drew extensively on the more object relational approach of Fairbairn and Winnicott. Nevertheless, although Guntrip believed that all these figures described important dimensions of psychological experience, he felt that they failed to acknowledge that layer which he called the "regressed ego." In his analysis of the "regressed ego," Guntrip made a valuable contribution to psychoanalytic theory and practice. However, because he thought that with this idea he had discovered the underlying cause of most psychological disturbances, he engaged in a form of reductionism and therefore undermined the value of his observations about this layer of psychological experience.
本文探讨了哈里·冈特里普对精神分析最重要的贡献或许是什么:即他的“退行自我”概念。在其精神分析工作过程中,他发现某些概念存在问题。因此,尽管他重视弗洛伊德的一些观点,但他对弗洛伊德强调本能的重要性提出了挑战。冈特里普随后广泛借鉴了费尔贝恩和温尼科特更具客体关系的方法。然而,尽管冈特里普认为所有这些人物都描述了心理体验的重要维度,但他觉得他们未能认识到他所称的“退行自我”这一层面。在对“退行自我”的分析中,冈特里普对精神分析理论与实践做出了宝贵贡献。然而,由于他认为凭借这一观点他发现了大多数心理障碍的潜在原因,他陷入了一种还原论形式,从而削弱了他对这一层面心理体验观察的价值。