Giuliani C A
Division of Physical Therapy, School of Medicine, University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill 27599-7135.
Phys Ther. 1991 Mar;71(3):248-59. doi: 10.1093/ptj/71.3.248.
The results from selective dorsal rhizotomy research suggest that therapists need to question some common clinical assumptions about movement dysfunction. The rationale for performing a selective dorsal rhizotomy is based on the clinical assumptions that spasticity is the underlying cause of disordered movement and that reducing or eliminating the spasticity will improve movement. This article reviews the literature related to movement dysfunction, the effects of selective dorsal rhizotomy, and the evidence for disordered motor control in children with spastic cerebral palsy. Selective dorsal rhizotomy appears to reduce spasticity and increase joint range of motion. Abnormal movement patterns, however, persist after the spasticity is reduced. Well-coordinated movement patterns are acquired slowly and appear to be related to an intense period of physical therapy. I argue that these results provide evidence that the presence of spasticity alone is an insufficient explanation for abnormal movement patterns. I propose that physical therapists redirect their efforts from developing methods for reducing spasticity to developing adequate assessment, treatment, and measurement techniques for assessing motor control in children with cerebral palsy. I believe we can maximize the functional potential of children with cerebral palsy by identifying problems related to motor control and applying sound principles of motor learning to treatment.
选择性背根切断术的研究结果表明,治疗师需要对一些关于运动功能障碍的常见临床假设提出质疑。进行选择性背根切断术的理论依据基于以下临床假设:痉挛是运动紊乱的根本原因,减轻或消除痉挛将改善运动。本文回顾了与运动功能障碍、选择性背根切断术的效果以及痉挛型脑瘫患儿运动控制紊乱的证据相关的文献。选择性背根切断术似乎能减轻痉挛并增加关节活动范围。然而,在痉挛减轻后,异常运动模式仍然存在。协调良好的运动模式获得缓慢,且似乎与一段强化物理治疗期有关。我认为这些结果证明,仅存在痉挛不足以解释异常运动模式。我提议物理治疗师将工作重点从开发减轻痉挛的方法,转向开发用于评估脑瘫患儿运动控制的充分评估、治疗和测量技术。我相信,通过识别与运动控制相关的问题并将合理的运动学习原则应用于治疗,我们可以最大限度地发挥脑瘫患儿的功能潜力。