Department of Surgery, University of Calgary, Calgary, Alberta, Canada.
J Surg Educ. 2009 Sep-Oct;66(5):288-91. doi: 10.1016/j.jsurg.2009.08.003.
Surgical stapling devices have been used for a variety of purposes in both laparoscopic and open surgery. Nevertheless, trainees rarely receive any focused instruction on their application and use. This study attempts to determine the baseline knowledge of surgical stapling devices possessed by surgical residents. Furthermore, we attempt to evaluate the effectiveness of a short didactic session in improving the trainee's knowledge of the use and function of surgical staplers.
A 20-question multiple-choice test was created to evaluate a general surgery resident's knowledge on the design and use of circular, linear, and laparoscopic surgical staplers. The test was administered before and after attending a 40-minute instructional session on surgical stapling devices. The tests were then scored by a data analyst.
A total of 26 residents of 39 in the residency program (26/39, 67%) participated. The pretest mean was 10.62/20 (53%), whereas the posttest mean was 15.38/20 (77%). These results were significantly different on paired samples t-test analysis (t((25)) = -10.3; p < 0.05). The mean pretest scores were also significantly different between resident levels (R1-R2, 9.50; R3-R5, 11.31; t((24)) = -2.10; p < 0.05). Senior-level residents scored higher on posttest analysis, but this result was not significant (R1-R2, 14.70; R3-R5, 15.81; t((24)) = -1.63; p > 0.05).
There is a deficiency of knowledge of surgical staplers in general surgery residents, more so in junior residents. Didactic instruction is effective in raising the level of knowledge of surgical staplers in all residents, up to a similar level. Surgical educators should consider implementing programs like these for staplers and other types of surgical equipment.
外科缝合器已被广泛应用于腹腔镜和开放性手术中,具有多种用途。然而,受训者在实际操作中很少接受有针对性的使用指导。本研究旨在确定外科住院医师对缝合器的基本了解,并评估短期教学课程对提高受训者对缝合器使用和功能的认识的效果。
设计了 20 个多项选择题,以评估普通外科住院医师对圆形、线性和腹腔镜缝合器设计和使用的了解。在参加 40 分钟的缝合器教学课程前后,对这些住院医师进行测试。然后由数据分析师对测试进行评分。
共有 39 名住院医师中的 26 名(26/39,67%)参与了这项研究。术前平均得分为 10.62/20(53%),而术后平均得分为 15.38/20(77%)。配对样本 t 检验分析显示,这一结果具有显著差异(t((25))=-10.3;p<0.05)。另外,不同住院医师级别的术前平均得分也存在显著差异(R1-R2 组为 9.50;R3-R5 组为 11.31;t((24))=-2.10;p<0.05)。高级别住院医师在术后分析中的得分较高,但这一结果无统计学意义(R1-R2 组为 14.70;R3-R5 组为 15.81;t((24))=-1.63;p>0.05)。
普通外科住院医师对缝合器的了解存在不足,低级别住院医师的了解更为缺乏。教学指导可有效提高所有住院医师对缝合器的了解程度,使其达到相似的水平。外科教育者应考虑为缝合器和其他类型的手术设备实施此类培训计划。