Bone mineral density in postmenopausal women treated with L-thyroxine.

PURPOSE

To determine if bone mineral density is decreased in postmenopausal women treated with 1-thyroxine, and, if any decrease is observed, whether it is related to overtreatment with thyroid hormone, to deficiency of calcitonin, or to other factors.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The study consisted of 19 postmenopausal women between 50 and 75 years of age treated with 1-thyroxine for 5 years or longer, and 19 matching control subjects with no thyroid disease. Bone mineral density of the spine and hip was measured by dual-photon absorptiometry. Plasma calcitonin concentrations and serum thyroid hormone levels were determined by radioimmunoassays.

RESULTS

The 1-thyroxine-treated women had lower bone density in the lumbar spine (1.013 g/cm2 [95% confidence interval, 0.945 to 1.081] versus 1.134 g/cm2 [1.026 to 1.242], p = 0.043); in the femoral neck (0.736 g/cm2 [0.694 to 0.778] versus 0.809 g/cm2 [0.747 to 0.872], p = 0.040); in Ward's triangle (0.576 g/cm2 [0.530 to 0.623] versus 0.694 g/cm2 [0.617 to 0.770], p = 0.011); and in the trochanteric area (0.626 g/cm2 [0.581 to 0.672] versus 0.722 g/cm2 [0.651 to 0.794], p = 0.027). The maximal increase in calcitonin following calcium infusion was 1.37 ng/L (95% confidence interval, -0.44 to 3.17) in the 1-thyroxine-treated patients versus 18.8 ng/L (95% confidence interval, 10.0 to 27.5) in normal women, p less than 0.001. The average dose of 1-thyroxine was 120 micrograms/day; 16 of the 19 patients had normal serum thyroxine levels. However, TSH levels were low in 13 of the 19, suggesting that 1-thyroxine treatment was supraphysiologic. Seven of the 19 patients had a history of hyperthyroidism in the distant past; these patients, considered separately, had significantly reduced bone density in the hip. The other 12 patients, considered separately, did not have a statistically significant loss of bone density.

CONCLUSIONS

Long-term 1-thyroxine therapy is associated with decreased density of the spine and hip. Since subclinical hyperthyroidism, decreased calcitonin responsiveness, and a history of hyperthyroidism were demonstrated in some or all of these patients, these factors must be considered as possible causes of the decreased bone density.