Department of Vertebrate Genomics, Max Planck Institute for Molecular Genetics, 14195 Berlin, Germany.
RNA. 2010 Feb;16(2):450-61. doi: 10.1261/rna.1755810. Epub 2009 Dec 29.
In recent years the improvements in high-throughput gene expression analysis have led to the discovery of numerous non-protein-coding RNA (npcRNA) molecules. They form an abundant class of untranslated RNAs that have shown to play a crucial role in different biochemical pathways in the cell. Reverse transcription quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) is an efficient tool to measure RNA abundance and gene expression levels in tiny amounts of material. Despite its sensitivity, the lack of appropriate internal controls necessary for accurate data analysis is a limiting factor for its application in npcRNA research. Common internal controls applied are protein-coding reference genes, also termed "housekeeping" genes (HKGs). However, their expression levels reportedly vary among tissues and different experimental conditions. Moreover, application of HKGs as reference in npcRNA expression analyses is questionable, due to the differences in biogenesis. To address the issue of optimal RT-qPCR normalizers in npcRNA analysis, we performed a systematic evaluation of 18 npcRNAs along with four common HKGs in 20 different human tissues. To determine the most suitable internal control with least expression variance, four evaluation strategies, geNORM, NormFinder, BestKeeper, and the comparative delta C(q) method, were applied. Our data strongly suggest that five npcRNAs, which we term housekeeping RNAs (HKRs), exhibit significantly better constitutive expression levels in 20 different human tissues than common HKGs. Determined HKRs are ideal candidates for RT-qPCR data normalization in human transcriptome analysis, and might also be used as reference genes irrespective of the nature of the genes under investigation.
近年来,高通量基因表达分析的改进导致了许多非蛋白编码 RNA (npcRNA) 分子的发现。它们形成了一类丰富的非翻译 RNA,已被证明在细胞内的不同生化途径中发挥着关键作用。逆转录实时定量聚合酶链反应 (RT-qPCR) 是一种测量少量材料中 RNA 丰度和基因表达水平的有效工具。尽管它具有敏感性,但缺乏准确数据分析所需的适当内部对照是其在 npcRNA 研究中应用的一个限制因素。常用的内部对照是编码蛋白的参考基因,也称为“管家”基因 (HKG)。然而,据报道,它们的表达水平在不同组织和不同实验条件下存在差异。此外,由于生物发生的差异,将 HKG 作为 npcRNA 表达分析的参考是值得怀疑的。为了解决 npcRNA 分析中最佳 RT-qPCR 正常化因子的问题,我们在 20 个人体组织中对 18 个 npcRNA 以及 4 个常见的 HKG 进行了系统评估。为了确定表达方差最小的最合适的内参,我们应用了四种评估策略,即 geNORM、NormFinder、BestKeeper 和比较 delta C(q) 法。我们的数据强烈表明,五个我们称之为管家 RNA (HKR) 的 npcRNA 在 20 个人体组织中的组成型表达水平明显优于常见的 HKG。确定的 HKR 是人类转录组分析中 RT-qPCR 数据归一化的理想候选者,并且无论研究基因的性质如何,它们也可以用作参考基因。