Georgy Ehab E, Carr Eloise Cj, Breen Alan C
Bournemouth University, School of Health and Social Care, Bournemouth, Dorset, BH1 3LT, UK.
Qual Prim Care. 2009;17(6):405-13.
Expectations may be a key element for improving quality of health care, yet several barriers interfere with understanding and optimising expectations in back pain primary care.
To review the literature related to expectations, back pain patients' and doctors' expectations and sources of unmatched expectations.
Review of qualitative and quantitative studies investigating back pain management in primary care settings, and eliciting patients' and/or doctors' pre-visit or post-visit expectations.
Reviewing the literature reveals that expectations are defined and conceptualised in various ways, with several terms used interchangeably, which suggests a lack of clear definition and conceptual framework. Patients have a wide range of specific expectations for care, which can be measured, and may play a vital role in their satisfaction: doctors also seem to have their own expectations. However, studies of such expectations are scarce and there is a lack of valid measurement tools to capture such aspects.
Shortcomings in literature included the use of different meanings and definitions for expectations, which interfered with understanding the results of previous research. Previous studies focused on patients' general rather than condition-specific expectations; no study explored doctors' expectations or the congruency between patients' and doctors' back pain-specific expectations.
There is a need for standardisation of definition in expectations research and a valid measurement tool that is condition specific. Understanding patients' and doctors' expectations may be a key factor for improving quality of care, in terms of both process and outcome.
期望可能是改善医疗保健质量的关键因素,但在腰痛初级保健中,存在几个障碍妨碍了对期望的理解和优化。
回顾与期望、腰痛患者和医生的期望以及期望不匹配的来源相关的文献。
回顾定性和定量研究,这些研究调查了初级保健环境中的腰痛管理,并引出患者和/或医生就诊前或就诊后的期望。
回顾文献发现,期望有多种定义和概念化方式,有几个术语可互换使用,这表明缺乏明确的定义和概念框架。患者对护理有广泛的具体期望,这些期望可以衡量,并且可能在他们的满意度中发挥重要作用:医生似乎也有自己的期望。然而,关于此类期望的研究很少,并且缺乏有效的测量工具来捕捉这些方面。
文献中的缺点包括对期望使用不同的含义和定义,这妨碍了对先前研究结果的理解。先前的研究侧重于患者的一般期望而非特定病情的期望;没有研究探讨医生的期望或患者与医生针对腰痛的特定期望之间的一致性。
期望研究需要定义标准化以及一种针对特定病情的有效测量工具。从过程和结果两方面来看,了解患者和医生的期望可能是提高护理质量的关键因素。