知识转化的初步报告:从研究环境到区域护理系统采用筛查和简短干预技术的经验教训。
A preliminary report of knowledge translation: lessons from taking screening and brief intervention techniques from the research setting into regional systems of care.
机构信息
Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA, USA.
出版信息
Acad Emerg Med. 2009 Nov;16(11):1225-33. doi: 10.1111/j.1553-2712.2009.00516.x.
This article describes a limited statewide dissemination of an evidence-based technology, screening, brief intervention, and referral to treatment (SBIRT), and evaluation of the effects on emergency department (ED) systems of care, utilizing the knowledge translation framework of reach, effectiveness, adoption, implementation, and maintenance (RE-AIM), using both quantitative and qualitative data sources. Screening and brief intervention (SBI) can detect high-risk and dependent alcohol and drug use in the medical setting, provide early intervention, facilitate access to specialty treatment when appropriate, and improve quality of care. Several meta-analyses demonstrate its effectiveness in primary care, and the federal government has developed a well-funded campaign to promote physician training and adoption of SBI. In the busy environment of the ED, with its competing priorities, researchers have tested a collaborative approach that relies on peer educators, with substance abuse treatment experience and broad community contact, as physician extenders. The ED-SBIRT model of care reflects clinician staff time constraints and resource limitations and is designed for the high rates of prevalence and increased acuity typical of ED patients. This report tracks services provided during dissemination of the ED-SBIRT extender model to seven EDs across a northeastern state, in urban, suburban, and rural community settings. Twelve health promotion advocates (HPAs) were hired, trained, and integrated into seven ED teams. Over an 18-month start-up period, HPAs screened 15,383 patients; of those, 4,899 were positive for high risk or dependent drinking and/or drug use. Among the positive screens, 4,035 (82%) received a brief intervention, and 57% of all positives were referred to the substance abuse treatment system and other community resources. Standardized, confidential interviews were conducted by two interviewers external to the program with 24 informants, including HPAs and their supervisors, clinicians, nurse managers, and ED directors across five sites. A detailed semistructured format was followed, and results were coded for thematic material. Barriers, challenges, and successes are described in the respondents' own words to convey their experience of this demonstration of SBIRT knowledge translation. Five of seven sites were sustained through the second year of the program, despite cutbacks in state funding. The dissemination process provided a number of important lessons for a large rollout. Successful implementation of the ED-SBIRT HPA model depends on 1) external funding for start-up; 2) local ED staff acting as champions to support the HPA role, resolve territorial issues, and promote a cultural shift in the ED treatment of drug and alcohol misuse from "treat and street" to prevention, based on a knowledge of the science of addiction; 3) sustainability planning from the beginning involving administrators, the billing and information technology departments, medical records coders, community service providers, and government agencies; and 4) creation and maintenance of a robust referral network to facilitate patient acceptance and access to substance abuse services.
本文描述了一项有限的全州范围内传播的循证技术,即筛查、简短干预和转介治疗(SBIRT),并利用可及性、有效性、采用、实施和维持(RE-AIM)的知识转化框架,利用定量和定性数据源,评估其对急诊部(ED)医疗系统的影响。筛查和简短干预(SBI)可以在医疗环境中发现高危和依赖酒精和药物的使用,提供早期干预,在适当的时候促进获得专业治疗,并改善医疗质量。几项荟萃分析表明,它在初级保健中的有效性,联邦政府已经开发了一项资金充足的运动,以促进医生培训和采用 SBI。在 ED 竞争激烈的环境中,研究人员测试了一种依赖于具有药物滥用治疗经验和广泛社区联系的同伴教育者的合作方法,作为医生的延伸。ED-SBIRT 护理模式反映了临床医生的时间限制和资源限制,专为 ED 患者常见的高患病率和增加的严重程度而设计。本报告跟踪了在东北部一个州的七个 ED 中传播 ED-SBIRT 扩展模型期间提供的服务,这些 ED 分别位于城市、郊区和农村社区。招聘、培训和整合了 12 名健康促进倡导者(HPAs)到七个 ED 团队中。在 18 个月的启动期间,HPAs 对 15383 名患者进行了筛查;其中,4899 名患者存在高危或依赖饮酒和/或药物使用的情况。在阳性筛查中,4035 名(82%)接受了简短干预,所有阳性患者中有 57%被转介到物质滥用治疗系统和其他社区资源。由两名程序外部的访谈者对来自五个地点的 24 名信息提供者,包括 HPAs 和他们的主管、临床医生、护士长和 ED 主任,进行了标准化、保密的访谈。采用详细的半结构化格式,并对主题材料进行编码。描述了受访者自己的话中的障碍、挑战和成功,以传达他们对 SBIRT 知识转化这一示范的体验。尽管州政府的资金削减,七个地点中的五个在项目的第二年仍得以维持。传播过程为大规模推广提供了许多重要的经验教训。ED-SBIRT HPA 模型的成功实施取决于以下因素:1)外部启动资金;2)ED 内部员工充当拥护者,支持 HPA 角色,解决领土问题,并根据成瘾科学知识,推动 ED 治疗药物和酒精滥用从“治疗和街头”转变为预防的文化转变;3)从一开始就进行可持续性规划,包括行政人员、计费和信息技术部门、病历编码员、社区服务提供者和政府机构;4)创建和维护强大的转介网络,以促进患者接受和获得物质滥用服务。