INSERM U887, University of Burgundy, Dijon, France.
J Strength Cond Res. 2010 Feb;24(2):458-64. doi: 10.1519/JSC.0b013e3181c06d25.
The purpose of this study was to investigate the neural and muscular changes associated with electrical stimulation (ES) training and subsequent detraining. Twenty healthy active men were randomized to receive (intervention group) or not (control group) 4 weeks of ES strength training followed by 4 weeks of detraining. Quadriceps ES training sessions (20 minutes per session, 4 sessions per week) were completed under isometric loading conditions. Quadriceps maximal voluntary contraction (MVC) strength, activation level, maximal electromyographic (EMG) activity, and excitation-contraction coupling properties were assessed before training, after training, and after detraining. Maximal voluntary contraction strength did not change after training but significantly increased after detraining (+21.5%; p < 0.05). Activation level (+7.3%) and maximal EMG activity (+27.9%) increased significantly after training and remained elevated after detraining (p < 0.05). Vastus lateralis M-wave amplitude did not change during the study period, whereas quadriceps contractile properties were significantly impaired after training but then recovered to pre-training values after detraining. We conclude that the maximal force-generating capacity of the quadriceps was unchanged after 4 weeks of ES strength training because of the interplay between neural (increased activation) and muscular (contractile impairment) changes. On the other hand, recovered contractile function and preserved activation after 4 weeks of detraining resulted in significant MVC strength increases. Quadriceps strength training via ES may induce overreaching and delayed adaptations and therefore should be used with caution. These findings may help in conceiving effective ES strength training programs for physically active subjects.
本研究旨在探讨电刺激(ES)训练及其随后的停训相关的神经和肌肉变化。20 名健康活跃的男性被随机分为接受(干预组)或不接受(对照组)4 周的 ES 力量训练,然后进行 4 周的停训。股四头肌 ES 训练(每次 20 分钟,每周 4 次)在等长负荷条件下进行。在训练前、训练后和停训后评估股四头肌最大自主收缩(MVC)强度、激活水平、最大肌电图(EMG)活动和兴奋-收缩偶联特性。训练后最大自主收缩强度没有变化,但停训后显著增加(+21.5%;p<0.05)。训练后激活水平(+7.3%)和最大 EMG 活动(+27.9%)显著增加,并在停训后保持升高(p<0.05)。研究期间,股外侧肌 M 波幅度没有变化,而股四头肌收缩特性在训练后显著受损,但在停训后恢复到训练前的水平。我们得出结论,由于神经(激活增加)和肌肉(收缩损伤)变化的相互作用,股四头肌的最大力量生成能力在 4 周的 ES 力量训练后没有改变。另一方面,停训 4 周后,收缩功能恢复和激活得以维持,导致 MVC 强度显著增加。通过 ES 进行股四头肌力量训练可能会引起过度训练和延迟适应,因此应谨慎使用。这些发现可能有助于为活跃的受试者设计有效的 ES 力量训练方案。