Clauss Marcus, Kleffner Helen, Kienzle Ellen
Clinic for Zoo Animals, Exotic Pets and Wildlife, Vetsuisse Faculty, University of Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland.
Zoo Biol. 2010 Nov-Dec;29(6):687-704. doi: 10.1002/zoo.20302.
Estimating the energy content is the first step in diet formulation, as it determines the amount of food eaten and hence the concentration of nutrients required to meet the animal's requirements. Additionally, being able to estimate the energy content of a diet empirically known to maintain body condition in an animal will facilitate an estimation of maintenance energy requirements. We collated data on nutrient composition of diets fed to captive wild canids, felids, hyenids, mustelids, pinnipeds, and ursids and the digestibility coefficients from the literature (45 species, 74 publications) to test whether differences in protein and fat digestibility could be detected between species groups, and whether approaches suggested for the estimation of dietary metabolizable energy (ME) content in domestic carnivores (NRC [2006] Nutrient requirements of dogs and cats. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.) can be applied to wild carnivores as well. Regressions of digestible protein or fat content vs. the crude protein (CP) or fat content indicated no relevant differences in the digestive physiology between the carnivore groups. For diets based on raw meat, fish, or whole prey, applying the calculation of ME using "Atwater factors" (16.7 kJ/g CP; 16.7 kJ/g nitrogen-free extracts; 37.7 kJ/g crude fat) provided estimates that compared well to experimental results. This study suggests that ME estimation in such diets is feasible without additional digestion trials. For comparative nutrition research, the study implicates that highly digestible diets typically fed in zoos offer little potential to elucidate differences between species or carnivore groups, but research on diets with higher proportions of difficult-to-digest components (fiber, connective tissues) is lacking.
估算能量含量是日粮配方制定的第一步,因为它决定了动物的采食量,进而决定了满足动物需求所需的营养物质浓度。此外,能够根据经验估算已知能维持动物体况的日粮能量含量,将有助于估算维持能量需求。我们整理了有关圈养野生犬科动物、猫科动物、鬣狗科动物、鼬科动物、鳍足类动物和熊科动物所喂食日粮的营养成分数据以及文献中的消化率系数(45个物种,74篇出版物),以测试是否能检测到不同物种组之间蛋白质和脂肪消化率的差异,以及美国国家研究委员会(2006年)《犬猫营养需求》(华盛顿特区:国家科学院出版社)中建议的估算家猫科动物日粮代谢能(ME)含量的方法是否也适用于野生猫科动物。可消化蛋白质或脂肪含量与粗蛋白(CP)或脂肪含量的回归分析表明,不同猫科动物组之间的消化生理没有显著差异。对于以生肉、鱼类或整个猎物为基础的日粮,使用“阿特沃特因子”(16.7 kJ/g CP;16.7 kJ/g无氮浸出物;37.7 kJ/g粗脂肪)计算代谢能,所得估算值与实验结果相当。本研究表明,在此类日粮中估算代谢能无需额外的消化试验。对于比较营养研究,该研究表明,动物园通常投喂的高消化率日粮几乎没有潜力阐明不同物种或猫科动物组之间的差异,但缺乏对含有较高比例难消化成分(纤维、结缔组织)日粮的研究。