School of Zoology, University of Tasmania, Private Bag 5, Hobart 7001 Tasmania, Australia.
Ecology. 2009 Dec;90(12):3379-92. doi: 10.1890/08-1763.1.
Most pathogens threatening to cause extinction of a host species are maintained on one or more reservoir hosts, in addition to the species that is threatened by disease. Further, most conventional host-pathogen theory assumes that transmission is related to host density, and therefore a pathogen should become extinct before its sole host. Tasmanian devil facial tumor disease is a recently emerged infectious cancer that has led to massive population declines and grave concerns for the future persistence of this largest surviving marsupial carnivore. Here we report the results of mark-recapture studies at six sites and use these data to estimate epidemiological parameters critical to both accurately assessing the risk of extinction from this disease and effectively managing this disease threat. Three sites were monitored from before or close to the time of disease arrival, and at three others disease was well established when trapping began, in one site for at least 10 years. We found no evidence for sex-specific differences in disease prevalence and little evidence of consistent seasonal variation in the force of infection. At all sites, the disease was maintained at high levels of prevalence (>50% in 2-3-year-old animals), despite causing major population declines. We also provide the first estimates of the basic reproductive rate R0 for this disease. Using a simple age-structured deterministic model, we show that our results are not consistent with transmission being proportional to the density of infected hosts but are consistent with frequency-dependent transmission. This conclusion is further supported by the observation that local disease prevalence in 2-3-year-olds still exceeds 50% at a site where population density has been reduced by up to 90% in the past 12 years. These findings lend considerable weight to concerns that this host-specific pathogen will cause the extinction of the Tasmanian devil. Our study highlights the importance of rapidly implementing monitoring programs to determine how transmission depends on host density and emphasizes the need for ongoing management strategies involving a disease-free "insurance population," along with ongoing field monitoring programs to confirm whether local population extinction occurs.
大多数对宿主物种构成灭绝威胁的病原体除了受疾病威胁的物种之外,还存在于一个或多个储主宿主中。此外,大多数传统的宿主-病原体理论假设传播与宿主密度有关,因此病原体应该在其唯一宿主之前灭绝。袋獾面部肿瘤疾病是一种新出现的传染性癌症,导致大量种群减少,并严重关注这种最大的现存有袋类食肉动物的未来生存。在这里,我们报告了在六个地点进行的标记-重捕研究的结果,并利用这些数据来估计对准确评估这种疾病灭绝风险和有效管理这种疾病威胁至关重要的流行病学参数。有三个地点是在疾病到达之前或接近到达时进行监测的,而另外三个地点在开始诱捕时疾病已经得到很好的控制,其中一个地点已经至少存在 10 年了。我们没有发现疾病流行率存在性别特异性差异的证据,也没有发现感染强度存在一致的季节性变化的证据。在所有地点,尽管疾病导致了大量种群减少,但疾病仍以高流行率(2-3 岁动物中>50%)维持着。我们还提供了这种疾病的基本繁殖率 R0 的首次估计。使用简单的年龄结构确定性模型,我们表明我们的结果与传播与感染宿主密度成正比不一致,而是与频率相关的传播一致。这一结论进一步得到了以下观察结果的支持:在过去 12 年中,人口密度减少了 90%的一个地点,2-3 岁动物的局部疾病流行率仍超过 50%。这些发现使得人们非常担心这种宿主特异性病原体将导致袋獾灭绝。我们的研究强调了迅速实施监测计划以确定传播如何取决于宿主密度的重要性,并强调了需要实施无疾病“保险种群”的持续管理策略,以及持续的现场监测计划,以确认是否发生局部种群灭绝。