Department of Neurology, Vanderbilt University Medical Center, Nashville, Tennessee 37232-2551, USA.
Mov Disord. 2010 Mar 15;25(4):466-73. doi: 10.1002/mds.22995.
Many adults with intellectual disabilities (ID) have spasticity, where increased muscle tone impairs activities of daily living (ADL) self-performance and care delivery. There are few reports of spasticity treatment for people with ID, and none of functionally meaningful outcomes. Our objective is to determine the effect of comprehensive spasticity management on ADL self-performance and care delivery. Baseline evaluation included repeated modified Ashworth and range of motion assessments, and timed and videotaped care task observations. Spasticity treatment was initiated immediately thereafter. Follow-up evaluation was conducted after spasticity management was optimized, one year after initiation. All individuals with spasticity at a single developmental center for whom treatment goals could be identified were included. Treatment was recommended by a neurologist from any accepted treatment for spasticity except oral medications, including botulinum neurotoxin A, intrathecal baclofen and orthopedic procedures. The main outcome measure is comparison of ease of videotaped care delivery, rated by direct caregivers blinded to participant treatment status. Spasticity treatment resulted in significant improvement across all outcome measures. Range of motion improved by 9 degrees (P = 0.005) and MAS by 0.4 (P = 0.022). Participants took 14% percent less time to complete tasks post-treatment (P = 0.01). Thirteen caregivers completed evaluations of 35 video pairs with an intra-class correlation of 0.9. After treatment, undergarment change (P = 0.031) and shirt change (P = 0.017) were rated easier, and all goals (P = 0.0006). Transfers trended toward improvement (P = 0.053). This study shows comprehensive spasticity management provides meaningful improvement in ADL care for patients with ID, which may improve quality of life and reduce caregiver burden.
许多成年智障人士(ID)患有痉挛,肌肉张力增加会影响日常生活活动(ADL)的自理能力和护理提供。关于 ID 患者痉挛治疗的报道很少,也没有任何关于功能有意义结果的报道。我们的目标是确定综合痉挛管理对 ADL 自理能力和护理提供的影响。基线评估包括重复改良 Ashworth 和关节活动度评估,以及计时和录像护理任务观察。随后立即开始痉挛治疗。在痉挛管理优化后一年进行随访评估,开始治疗后一年进行随访评估。所有在单一发育中心患有痉挛且可以确定治疗目标的患者均包括在内。治疗由任何可接受的痉挛治疗方法(除口服药物外)的神经科医生推荐,包括肉毒杆菌神经毒素 A、鞘内巴氯芬和矫形手术。主要观察指标是直接护理人员对录像护理提供的容易程度进行评分,护理人员对参与者治疗状况不知情。痉挛治疗在所有结果测量中均显著改善。关节活动度增加了 9 度(P = 0.005),MAS 增加了 0.4(P = 0.022)。治疗后,参与者完成任务的时间减少了 14%(P = 0.01)。13 名护理人员对 35 对视频进行了评估,组内相关系数为 0.9。治疗后,更换内衣(P = 0.031)和更换衬衫(P = 0.017)更容易,所有目标(P = 0.0006)。转移趋势有所改善(P = 0.053)。这项研究表明,综合痉挛管理为 ID 患者的 ADL 护理提供了有意义的改善,这可能会提高生活质量并减轻护理人员的负担。