Department of Diagnostic Radiology, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China.
Br J Radiol. 2010 Feb;83(986):152-8. doi: 10.1259/bjr/29879495.
This study aimed to estimate the radiation dose and cancer risk to adults in England, the USA and Hong Kong associated with retrospectively and prospectively electrocardiogram (ECG)-gated coronary computed tomography angiography (CTA) using currently practised protocols in Hong Kong. The doses were simulated using the ImPACT spreadsheet. For retrospectively ECG-gated CTA with pitches of 0.2, 0.22 and 0.24, the effective doses were 27.7, 23.6 and 20.7 mSv, respectively, for males and 23.6, 20.0 and 18.8 mSv, respectively, for females. For prospectively ECG-gated CTA, the effective dose was 3.7 mSv for both males and females. A table of lifetime attributable risks (LAR) of cancer incidence was set up for the English population for the purpose of estimating cancer risk induced by low-dose radiation exposure, as previously reported for US and Hong Kong populations. From the tables, the LAR of cancer incidence for a representative 50-year-old subject was calculated for retrospectively ECG-gated CTA to be 0.112% and 0.227% for English males and females, respectively, 0.103% and 0.228% for US males and females, respectively, and was comparatively higher at 0.137% and 0.370% for Hong Kong males and females, respectively; for prospectively ECG-gated CTA, the corresponding values were calculated to be 0.014% and 0.035% for English males and females, respectively, and 0.013% and 0.036% for US males and females, respectively, and again were higher at 0.017% and 0.060% for Hong Kong males and females, respectively. Our study shows that prospectively ECG-gated CTA reduces radiation dose and cancer risks by up to 87% compared with retrospectively ECG-gated CTA.
本研究旨在估算香港现行协议下回顾性和前瞻性心电门控冠状动脉计算机断层扫描血管造影(CTA)检查致英国、美国和香港成年人的辐射剂量和癌症风险。采用 ImPACT 电子表格模拟剂量。对于回顾性心电门控 CTA,管电压分别为 0.2、0.22 和 0.24 时,男性有效剂量分别为 27.7、23.6 和 20.7 mSv,女性分别为 23.6、20.0 和 18.8 mSv。对于前瞻性心电门控 CTA,男性和女性的有效剂量均为 3.7 mSv。根据之前报道的美国和香港人群数据,为估算低剂量辐射诱发癌症风险,为英国人群设立了终生归因风险(LAR)癌症发病率表。从表中可以计算出,代表 50 岁男性和女性进行回顾性心电门控 CTA 的 LAR 分别为 0.112%和 0.227%,美国男性和女性分别为 0.103%和 0.228%,而香港男性和女性分别为 0.137%和 0.370%,风险较高;前瞻性心电门控 CTA 的相应值分别为 0.014%和 0.035%,美国男性和女性分别为 0.013%和 0.036%,而香港男性和女性的风险再次升高,分别为 0.017%和 0.060%。本研究表明,与回顾性心电门控 CTA 相比,前瞻性心电门控 CTA 可将辐射剂量和癌症风险降低多达 87%。