Yavaş Mehmet, McLeod Sharynne
Florida International University, Miami, FL 33199, USA.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2010 Jan;24(3):177-87. doi: 10.3109/02699200903362935.
Two member onset consonant clusters with /s/ as the first member (#sC onsets) behave differently from other double onset consonant clusters in English. Phonological explanations of children's consonant cluster production have been posited to predict children's speech acquisition. The aim of this study was to consider the role of the Sonority Sequencing Principle (SSP), homorganicity, headedness, and factorial typology in the explanation of productions of consonant clusters by children with phonological disorders. Thirty monolingual English-speaking children with phonological disorders produced words commencing with #sC: /s/+stop (/sT/), /s/+nasal (/sN/), /sl/, and /sw/. There was wide individual variation between participants. Overall, there was an increase in accuracy of consonant cluster production as the sonority indices of the second element of the cluster increased: there was significantly greater accuracy of /sl/ than /sN/ and significantly greater accuracy of /sN/ than /sT/. However, /sw/ targets only followed the SSP for phonologically accurate (but not phonetically accurate) productions. Correct renditions justified the binary grouping of the SSP-following vs SSP-violating separation. Homorganicity of the cluster was not a factor in determining relative accuracy of the targets. The percentage of correct renditions justified the /s/+[-continuant] vs /s/+[+continuant] binary separation. There were several counterexamples of predictions of the headedness approach. Thus, sonority and factorial typology were found to be useful in predicting /s/ consonant cluster acquisition of children with phonological disorders.
以/s/作为第一个成员的双成员起始辅音连缀(#sC起始)在英语中的表现与其他双起始辅音连缀不同。关于儿童辅音连缀发音的音系学解释已被提出,以预测儿童的语音习得情况。本研究的目的是探讨响度顺序原则(SSP)、同部位性、首位性和阶元类型学在解释语音障碍儿童辅音连缀发音中的作用。30名患有语音障碍的单语英语儿童说出了以#sC开头的单词:/s/+塞音(/sT/)、/s/+鼻音(/sN/)、/sl/和/sw/。参与者之间存在很大的个体差异。总体而言,随着辅音连缀第二个元素的响度指数增加,辅音连缀发音的准确性有所提高:/sl/的准确性显著高于/sN/,/sN/的准确性显著高于/sT/。然而,/sw/目标仅在语音准确(但非语音学准确)的发音中遵循SSP。正确的发音证明了遵循SSP与违反SSP的二分法分组是合理的。连缀的同部位性不是决定目标相对准确性的因素。正确发音的百分比证明了/s/+[-延续音]与/s/+[+延续音]的二分法是合理的。首位性方法的预测存在几个反例。因此,发现响度和阶元类型学在预测语音障碍儿童的/s/辅音连缀习得方面是有用的。