Yavas Mehmet, Ben-David Avivit, Gerrits Ellen, Kristoffersen Kristian E, Simonsen Hanne G
Florida International University, Miami, FL 33199, USA.
Clin Linguist Phon. 2008 Jun;22(6):421-41. doi: 10.1080/02699200701875864.
This paper examines the findings and implications of the cross-linguistic acquisition of #sC clusters in relation to sonority patterns. Data from individual studies on English, Dutch, Norwegian, and Hebrew are compared for accuracy of production as well as the reductions with respect to potential differences across subtypes of #sC groups. In all four languages, a great deal of variability occurred both within and across children, but a number of general patterns were noted. While all four languages showed similar behaviour in reduction patterns, clear differences between the three Germanic languages-English, Dutch, and Norwegian-and Hebrew were found in the accuracy rate of #sC clusters that have a larger sonority distance between C1 and C2, in a binary split of /s/+[+cont.] versus /s/+[-cont.], and in #sC clusters versus non-/s/-clusters. Patterns in cluster reductions were, in general, supportive of the factorial typology of Pater and Barlow, while pointing at some difficulties for the predictions of the headedness approach advanced by Goad and Rose, and Jongstra. This cross-linguistic description of patterns of s-clusters increases our knowledge of typical phonological development and helps selecting targets in clinical context.
本文考察了与响度模式相关的#sC音丛跨语言习得的研究结果及影响。对关于英语、荷兰语、挪威语和希伯来语的个体研究数据进行了比较,涉及发音准确性以及#sC音丛各亚型之间潜在差异方面的简化情况。在所有这四种语言中,儿童个体内部和个体之间都存在很大的变异性,但也发现了一些普遍模式。虽然所有四种语言在简化模式上表现出相似的行为,但在C1和C2之间响度距离较大的#sC音丛的准确率方面,在/s/ + [+送气]与/s/ + [-送气]的二分法中,以及在#sC音丛与非/s/音丛方面,发现日耳曼语族的三种语言——英语、荷兰语和挪威语——与希伯来语之间存在明显差异。音丛简化模式总体上支持了帕特和巴洛的阶元类型学,同时也指出了戈德、罗斯以及琼斯特拉提出的词首方法在预测方面存在的一些困难。这种对s音丛模式的跨语言描述增加了我们对典型语音发展的了解,并有助于在临床环境中选择目标。