Magnani Jared W, Mazzini Michael J, Sullivan Lisa M, Williamson MaryAnn, Ellinor Patrick T, Benjamin Emelia J
Boston University School of Medicine, Section of Cardiology, School of Public Health, Boston, MA 01702-5827, USA.
Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol. 2010 Jan;15(1):77-84. doi: 10.1111/j.1542-474X.2009.00343.x.
P-wave indices of maximum P-wave duration and P-wave dispersion have been examined in a broad array of cardiovascular and noncardiovascular disease states. The P-wave indices literature has been highly heterogeneous in measurement methodologies, described quality control metrics, and distribution of values. We therefore sought to determine the reproducibility of P-wave indices in a community-based cohort.
P-wave indices were measured in sequential subjects enrolled in the Framingham Heart Study. Electrocardiograms were obtained at the 11th biennial visit of the Original Cohort (n = 250) and the initial visit of the Offspring Cohort (n = 252). We determined the mean P-wave durations, interlead correlations, and P-wave indices. We then chose 20 ECGs, 10 from each cohort, and assessed intrarater and interrater variability.
The maximum P-wave duration ranged from 71 to 162 ms with mean of 112 + or - 12 ms. The minimum P-wave duration ranged from 35 to 103 ms with mean of 65 + or - 10 ms. P-wave dispersion ranged from 12 to 82 ms. The mean P-wave dispersion was 48 + or - 12 ms (40-56). The intrarater intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) was r = 0.80 for maximum P-wave duration and r = 0.82 for P-wave dispersion. The interrater ICC was 0.56 for maximum P-wave duration and 0.70 for P-wave dispersion.
We demonstrated excellent intrarater reproducibility and fair interrater reproducibility for calculating P-wave indices. Reproducibility is frequently lacking in studies of P-wave indices, but is an essential component for the field's growth and epidemiologic contribution.
在众多心血管疾病和非心血管疾病状态中,均对最大P波时限和P波离散度等P波指标进行了研究。P波指标文献在测量方法、所描述的质量控制指标以及数值分布方面存在高度异质性。因此,我们试图确定基于社区的队列中P波指标的可重复性。
在参加弗雷明汉心脏研究的连续受试者中测量P波指标。在原队列的第11次两年一次随访(n = 250)和子代队列的首次随访(n = 252)时获取心电图。我们确定了平均P波时限、导联间相关性和P波指标。然后从每个队列中选择20份心电图(各10份),评估评分者内和评分者间的变异性。
最大P波时限范围为71至162毫秒,平均为112±12毫秒。最小P波时限范围为35至103毫秒,平均为65±10毫秒。P波离散度范围为12至82毫秒。平均P波离散度为48±12毫秒(40 - 56)。评分者内组内相关系数(ICC)对于最大P波时限为r = 0.80,对于P波离散度为r = 0.82。评分者间ICC对于最大P波时限为0.56,对于P波离散度为0.70。
我们证明了计算P波指标时具有出色的评分者内可重复性和一般的评分者间可重复性。P波指标研究中常常缺乏可重复性,但这是该领域发展和流行病学贡献的重要组成部分。