Adams Jenny, Schneider Jonna, Hubbard Matthew, McCullough-Shock Tiffany, Cheng Dunlei, Simms Kay, Hartman Julie, Hinton Paul, Strauss Danielle
Cardiac Rehabilitation Department, Baylor Jack and Jane Hamilton Heart and Vascular Hospital, Dallas, Texas (Adams, Hubbard, McCullough-Shock, Simms, Strauss); The Heart Hospital Baylor Plano, Plano, Texas (Schneider, Hartman); the Institute for Health Care Research and Improvement, Baylor Health Care System, Dallas, Texas (Cheng); and the Police Training Section, Dallas Police Academy, Dallas, Texas (Hinton).
Proc (Bayl Univ Med Cent). 2010 Jan;23(1):7-10. doi: 10.1080/08998280.2010.11928571.
This study was designed to measure the functional capacity of healthy subjects during strenuous simulated police tasks, with the goal of developing occupation-specific training for cardiac rehabilitation of police officers. A calibrated metabolic instrument and an oxygen consumption data collection mask were used to measure the oxygen consumption and heart rates of 30 Dallas Police Academy officers and cadets as they completed an 8-event obstacle course that simulated chasing, subduing, and handcuffing a suspect. Standard target heart rates (85% of age-predicted maximum heart rate, or 0.85 x [220 - age]) and metabolic equivalents (METs) were calculated; a matched-sample t test based on differences between target and achieved heart rate and MET level was used for statistical analysis. Peak heart rates during the obstacle course simulation were significantly higher than the standard target heart rates (those at which treadmill stress tests in physicians' offices are typically stopped) (t(29) = 12.81, P < 0.001) and significantly higher than the suggested maximum of 150 beats/min during cardiac rehabilitation training (t(29) = 17.84, P < 0.001). Peak MET levels during the obstacle course simulation were also significantly higher than the goal level (8 METs) that patients typically achieve in a cardiac rehabilitation program (t(29) = 14.73, P < 0.001). We conclude that police work requires a functional capacity greater than that typically attained in traditional cardiac rehabilitation programs. Rehabilitation professionals should consider performing maximal stress tests and increasing the intensity of cardiac rehabilitation workouts to effectively train police officers who have had a cardiac event.
本研究旨在测量健康受试者在高强度模拟警察任务期间的功能能力,目标是为警察的心脏康复制定特定职业培训。使用校准的代谢仪器和耗氧量数据收集面罩,测量30名达拉斯警察学院的警官和学员在完成一个模拟追捕、制服和给嫌疑人戴手铐的包含8个项目的障碍课程时的耗氧量和心率。计算标准目标心率(年龄预测最大心率的85%,即0.85×[220 - 年龄])和代谢当量(METs);基于目标心率与实际达到的心率和MET水平之间的差异,采用配对样本t检验进行统计分析。障碍课程模拟期间的峰值心率显著高于标准目标心率(医生办公室跑步机压力测试通常停止时的心率)(t(29) = 12.81,P < 0.001),且显著高于心脏康复训练期间建议的最大心率150次/分钟(t(29) = 17.84,P < 0.001)。障碍课程模拟期间的峰值MET水平也显著高于患者在心脏康复计划中通常达到的目标水平(8 METs)(t(29) = 14.73,P < 0.001)。我们得出结论,警察工作所需的功能能力大于传统心脏康复计划中通常达到的能力。康复专业人员应考虑进行最大压力测试,并增加心脏康复锻炼的强度,以有效训练发生过心脏事件的警察。