Crocker Matthew, Jones Timothy L, Rich Philip, Bell B Anthony, Papadopoulos Marios C
Academic Neurosurgery Unit, St George's University of London, London, UK.
Br J Neurosurg. 2010 Feb;24(1):46-50. doi: 10.3109/02688690903374067.
MRI scanning has historically been considered difficult to interpret in the early period following lumbar spine surgery, and hence of limited value. We investigate the hypothesis that MRI scanning within 6 weeks of lumbar spine surgery cannot accurately diagnose neural compression in symptomatic patients, and define the utility of postoperative MRI in this context.
A series of 32 consecutive patients had early postoperative MRI following lumbar discectomy or laminectomy for continued, worsening or new symptoms of neural compression. The neuroradiologists' reports were evaluated for the reported presence of neural compression and confidence level (low, medium, high). These MRI findings were then compared to the patients' subsequent course and findings of any surgery performed.
Twenty of 29 scans (69%) were confidently predictive of the correct treatment pathway (reoperation with positive finding or conservative treatment with a good outcome) whereas 3/3 (100%) patients who had conservative management despite the MRI confidently suggesting compression had poor outcome. The MRI is highly likely to influence management: 11/14 (79%) patients with scans suggesting neural compression had revision surgery and 18/18 (100%) patients with no neural compression on MRI were managed conservatively.
Our data suggest that early MRI scanning after lumbar laminectomy or discectomy accurately detects neural compression at the surgery site in patients with continued or worsening symptoms.
在腰椎手术后的早期阶段,MRI扫描在历史上一直被认为难以解读,因此价值有限。我们研究了这样一个假设,即在腰椎手术后6周内进行的MRI扫描无法准确诊断有症状患者的神经受压情况,并确定在此背景下术后MRI的效用。
对32例连续患者在接受腰椎间盘切除术或椎板切除术后,因持续、加重或新出现的神经受压症状进行了早期术后MRI检查。对神经放射科医生的报告进行评估,以确定报告中是否存在神经受压情况以及信心水平(低、中、高)。然后将这些MRI检查结果与患者随后的病程以及所进行的任何手术的结果进行比较。
29次扫描中有20次(69%)能够可靠地预测正确的治疗途径(发现阳性结果后进行再次手术或保守治疗且效果良好),而3/3(100%)尽管MRI明确提示有压迫但接受保守治疗的患者效果不佳。MRI极有可能影响治疗决策:14例扫描提示神经受压的患者中有11例(79%)接受了翻修手术,而MRI未显示神经受压的18例患者(100%)均接受了保守治疗。
我们的数据表明,在接受椎板切除术或椎间盘切除术后,早期MRI扫描能够准确检测出有持续或加重症状患者手术部位的神经受压情况。