Steiner Marcel, Menghini Giorgio, Thomet Eshara, Jäger Armin, Pfister Jörg, Imfeld Thomas
Clinic for Preventive Dentistry, Periodontology and Cariology, Dental Center, University of Zurich, Switzerland.
Schweiz Monatsschr Zahnmed. 2010;120(1):12-20.
In 1996 and 2006, recruits of the Swiss army participated in a dental survey. Similarly in 1995/96 and 2004/05, randomly selected schoolchildren from 16 rural communities of the Canton of Zurich participated in a dental survey. As part of these surveys, color slides were taken of the incisor teeth of all recruits, as well as of third and fourth grade schoolchildren. The slides (N = 2049) were examined for the presence of fluoride-associated enamel opacities (FOP), using the Thyl-strup-Fejerskov (TF) index. Two examiners (A and B) assessed all slides. The examiners were blind as to the year of survey. Examiner A recorded prevalences of FOP between 18% and 27% depending on population; examiner B recorded prevalences between 7% and 12%. The examiners' influence on the estimation of the prevalence was obvious. The prevalences reported should, therefore, be considered as rough estimates. FOP of TF score 2 were only observed in approximately 1% of the participants. One examiner recorded a TF score 3 in a single individual. FOP therefore are not a cosmetic problem and certainly not a public health concern. The prevalence of FOP decreased slightly during observation period I (recruits born 1975-77 vs 1985-87) and period II (school children born 1985-87 vs 1994-96). However, the decline was statistically supported in only one instance (Period I, Examiner B).
1996年和2006年,瑞士军队新兵参加了一项牙科调查。同样,在1995/96年和2004/05年,从苏黎世州16个农村社区随机抽取的学童参加了一项牙科调查。作为这些调查的一部分,对所有新兵以及三年级和四年级学童的门牙拍摄了彩色幻灯片。使用蒂尔斯特鲁普-费耶斯科夫(TF)指数检查这些幻灯片(N = 2049)是否存在与氟相关的釉质混浊(FOP)。两名检查人员(A和B)评估了所有幻灯片。检查人员对调查年份不知情。检查人员A记录的FOP患病率在18%至27%之间,具体取决于人群;检查人员B记录的患病率在7%至12%之间。检查人员对患病率估计的影响很明显。因此,报告的患病率应被视为粗略估计。TF评分为2的FOP仅在约1%的参与者中观察到。一名检查人员在一个个体中记录到TF评分为3。因此,FOP不是一个美容问题,当然也不是一个公共卫生问题。在观察期I(1975 - 77年出生的新兵与1985 - 87年出生的新兵)和观察期II(1985 - 87年出生的学童与1994 - 96年出生的学童)期间,FOP的患病率略有下降。然而,只有在一个实例中(观察期I,检查人员B)下降具有统计学支持。