Department of Robotics, Brain and Cognitive Sciences, Italian Institute of Technology, Genoa, Italy.
Exp Brain Res. 2010 May;202(3):693-707. doi: 10.1007/s00221-010-2175-9. Epub 2010 Feb 20.
Skillful manipulation of objects often requires the spatio-temporal coordination of both hands and, at the same time, the compensation of environmental forces. In bimanual coordination, movements of the two hands may be coupled because each hand needs to compensate the forces generated by the other hand or by an object operated by both hands (dynamic coupling), or because the two hands share the same workspace (spatial coupling). We examined how spatial coupling influences bimanual coordination, by looking at the adaptation of velocity-dependent force fields during a task in which the two hands simultaneously perform center-out reaching movements with the same initial position and the same targets, equally spaced on a circle. Subjects were randomly allocated to two groups, which differed in terms of the force fields they were exposed to: in one group (CW-CW), force fields had equal clockwise orientations in both hands; in the other group (CCW-CW), they had opposite orientations. In both groups, in randomly selected trials (catch trials) of the adaptation phase, the force fields were unexpectedly removed. Adaptation was quantified in terms of the changes of directional error for both hand trajectories. Bimanual coordination was quantified in terms of inter-limb longitudinal and sideways displacements, in force field and in catch trials. Experimental results indicate that both arms could simultaneously adapt to the two force fields. However, in the CCW-CW group, adaptation was incomplete for the movements from the central position to the more distant targets with respect to the body. In addition, in this group the left hand systematically leads in the movements toward targets on the left of the starting position, whereas the right hand leads in the movements to targets on the right. We show that these effects are due to a gradual sideways shift of the hands, so that during movements the left hand tends to consistently remain at the left of the right hand. These findings can be interpreted in terms of a neural mechanism of bimanual coordination/interaction, triggered by the force field adaptation process but largely independent from it, which opposes movements that may lead to the crossing of the hands. In conclusion, our results reveal a concurrent interplay of two task-dependent modules of motor-cognitive processing: an adaptive control module and a 'protective' module that opposes potentially 'dangerous' (or cognitively costly) bimanual interactions.
熟练地操纵物体通常需要双手的时空协调,同时还需要补偿环境力。在双手协调运动中,两只手的运动可能会耦合,因为每只手都需要补偿另一只手或两只手共同操作的物体产生的力(动态耦合),或者因为两只手共享相同的工作空间(空间耦合)。我们通过观察在一项任务中,两只手同时以相同的初始位置和相同的目标进行中心向外的伸展运动,目标均匀地分布在一个圆上,来研究空间耦合如何影响双手协调。在适应阶段,受试者被随机分配到两个组,这两个组接触到的力场不同:在一个组(CW-CW)中,两只手的力场具有相同的顺时针方向;在另一个组(CCW-CW)中,它们的方向相反。在这两个组中,在适应阶段的随机选择试验(捕获试验)中,力场会意外地被移除。适应程度通过两只手轨迹的方向误差变化来量化。双手协调程度通过力场和捕获试验中的肢体间纵向和侧向位移来量化。实验结果表明,两只手臂可以同时适应两种力场。然而,在 CCW-CW 组中,对于从中点到离身体更远的目标的运动,适应性不完全。此外,在这个组中,左手在朝着起始位置左侧的目标运动时系统地领先,而右手在朝着右侧的目标运动时领先。我们表明,这些效应是由于手的逐渐侧向移位,使得在运动过程中,左手倾向于始终保持在右手的左侧。这些发现可以用双手协调/交互的神经机制来解释,该机制由力场适应过程触发,但在很大程度上独立于该过程,该机制反对可能导致双手交叉的运动。总之,我们的研究结果揭示了两种与任务相关的运动认知加工模块的并发相互作用:一个自适应控制模块和一个“保护性”模块,该模块反对潜在的“危险”(或认知成本高)的双手交互。