Franklin David W, So Udell, Burdet Etienne, Kawato Mitsuo
National Institute of Information and Communications Technology, Keihanna Science City, Kyoto, Japan.
PLoS One. 2007 Dec 19;2(12):e1336. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0001336.
When learning to perform a novel sensorimotor task, humans integrate multi-modal sensory feedback such as vision and proprioception in order to make the appropriate adjustments to successfully complete the task. Sensory feedback is used both during movement to control and correct the current movement, and to update the feed-forward motor command for subsequent movements. Previous work has shown that adaptation to stable dynamics is possible without visual feedback. However, it is not clear to what degree visual information during movement contributes to this learning or whether it is essential to the development of an internal model or impedance controller.
METHODOLOGY/PRINCIPLE FINDINGS: We examined the effects of the removal of visual feedback during movement on the learning of both stable and unstable dynamics in comparison with the case when both vision and proprioception are available. Subjects were able to learn to make smooth movements in both types of novel dynamics after learning with or without visual feedback. By examining the endpoint stiffness and force after learning it could be shown that subjects adapted to both types of dynamics in the same way whether they were provided with visual feedback of their trajectory or not. The main effects of visual feedback were to increase the success rate of movements, slightly straighten the path, and significantly reduce variability near the end of the movement.
CONCLUSIONS/SIGNIFICANCE: These findings suggest that visual feedback of the hand during movement is not necessary for the adaptation to either stable or unstable novel dynamics. Instead vision appears to be used to fine-tune corrections of hand trajectory at the end of reaching movements.
在学习执行一项新的感觉运动任务时,人类会整合多模态感觉反馈,如视觉和本体感觉,以便做出适当调整以成功完成任务。感觉反馈在运动过程中既用于控制和纠正当前运动,也用于更新后续运动的前馈运动指令。先前的研究表明,在没有视觉反馈的情况下适应稳定动力学是可能的。然而,尚不清楚运动过程中的视觉信息在多大程度上有助于这种学习,或者它对于内部模型或阻抗控制器的发展是否至关重要。
方法/主要发现:我们研究了与视觉和本体感觉都可用的情况相比,运动过程中去除视觉反馈对稳定和不稳定动力学学习的影响。在有或没有视觉反馈的情况下学习后,受试者都能够学会在两种新型动力学中做出平滑运动。通过检查学习后的端点刚度和力可以发现,无论是否提供其轨迹的视觉反馈,受试者以相同的方式适应两种类型的动力学。视觉反馈的主要作用是提高运动成功率、略微拉直路径并显著降低运动终点附近的变异性。
结论/意义:这些发现表明,运动过程中手部的视觉反馈对于适应稳定或不稳定的新型动力学并非必要。相反,视觉似乎用于在伸手运动结束时对手部轨迹的校正进行微调。