Chongsuvivatwong Virasakdi, Bachtiar Hafni, Chowdhury Mahbub Elahi, Fernando Sunil, Suwanrath Chitkasaem, Kor-Anantakul Ounjai, Tuan Le Anh, Lim Apiradee, Lumbiganon Pisake, Manandhar Bekha, Muchtar Masrul, Nahar Lutfan, Hieu Nguyen Trong, Fang Pan Xiao, Prasertcharoensuk Witoon, Radnaabarzar Erdenetungalag, Sibuea Daulat, Than Kyu Kyu, Tharnpaisan Piangjit, Thach Tran Son, Rowe Patrick
Epidemiology Unit, Faculty of Medicine, Prince of Songkla University, Hat Yai, Thailand.
J Obstet Gynaecol Res. 2010 Feb;36(1):45-51. doi: 10.1111/j.1447-0756.2009.01100.x.
To compare the mortality, morbidity of emergency and elective cesarean section with vaginal delivery among Asian teaching hospitals.
Hospital based prospective study at 12 centers of 9 countries.
12 591 vaginal deliveries, 3062 elective and 4328 emergency cesarean section were followed up to 5 days postpartum. Maternal deaths (95% CI) per 1000 births among vaginal deliveries being 0.47 (0.17, 1.03) was not significantly different from 0.31 (0.01, 1.73) of elective cesarean section and both rates were significantly lower than 2.87 (1.53, 4.91) per 1000 births of emergency section. The vaginal delivery group had significantly lower incidences of all major complication except significantly higher chance of secondary operations and non-significantly different risk for endometritis. Corresponding neonatal mortality per 1000 deliveries among the three groups were 7 (5.6, 8.6), 2.2 (0.9, 4.6) and 12.4 (9.3, 16.2) (P < 0.001). Vaginal delivery also had higher rates of severe asphyxia and palsy than elective cesarean section.
Maternal complications were increased by cesarean delivery but elective section may reduce neonatal complication.
比较亚洲教学医院中急诊剖宫产、择期剖宫产与阴道分娩的死亡率和发病率。
在9个国家的12个中心进行基于医院的前瞻性研究。
对12591例阴道分娩、3062例择期剖宫产和4328例急诊剖宫产进行了产后5天的随访。每1000例阴道分娩中的孕产妇死亡(95%可信区间)为0.47(0.17,1.03),与择期剖宫产的0.31(0.01,1.73)无显著差异,且这两个率均显著低于每1000例急诊剖宫产中的2.87(1.53,4.91)。阴道分娩组除二次手术几率显著较高和子宫内膜炎风险无显著差异外,所有主要并发症的发生率均显著较低。三组中每1000例分娩对应的新生儿死亡率分别为7(5.6,8.6)、2.2(0.9,4.6)和12.4(9.3,16.2)(P<0.001)。阴道分娩的重度窒息和麻痹发生率也高于择期剖宫产。
剖宫产会增加孕产妇并发症,但择期剖宫产可能会降低新生儿并发症。