Joint Graduate Group in Bioengineering, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Bone. 2010 Jun;46(6):1652-60. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2010.02.021. Epub 2010 Feb 25.
Regional variation in trabecular structure across axial sections is often obscured by the conventional global analysis, which takes an average value for the entire trabecular compartment. The objective of this study is to characterize spatial variability in trabecular structure within a cross-section at the distal radius and tibia, and gender and age effects using in vivo high-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography (HR-pQCT). HR-pQCT images of the distal radius and tibia were acquired from 146 healthy individuals aged 20-78 years. Trabecular bone volume fraction (BV/TV), number (Tb.N), thickness (Tb.Th), separation (Tb.Sp), and heterogeneity (Tb.1/N.SD) were obtained in a total of 11 regions-the entire trabecular compartment (the global means), inner, outer, and eight defined subregions. Regional variations were examined with respect to the global means, and compared between women and men, and between young (20-29 years old) and elderly (65-79 years old) adults. Substantial regional variations in trabecular bone structure at the distal radius and tibia were revealed (e.g. BV/TV varied -40% to +57% and -59% to +100% of the global means, respectively, for elderly women). The inner-lateral (IL) subregion had low BV/TV, Tb.N, and Tb.Th, and low Tb.Sp and Tb.1/N.SD at both sites; the opposite was true in the outer-anterior (OA) subregion at the distal radius and the outer-medial (OM) and -posterior (OP) subregions at the distal tibia. Gender differences were most pronounced in the inner-anterior (IA) subregion compared to the other regions or the global mean differences at both sites. Trabecular structure associated with age and differed between young and elderly adults predominantly in the inner-posterior (IP) subregion at the distal radius and in the IL and IA subregions at the distal tibia; on the other hand, it remained unchanged in the OA subregion at the distal radius and in the OM subregion at the distal tibia for both women and men. This study demonstrated that not only the conventional global analysis can obscure regional differences, but also assuming bone status from that of smaller subregion may introduce a confounding sampling error. Therefore, a combined approach of investigating the entire region, each subregion, and the cortical compartment may offer more complete information.
传统的全局分析通常会掩盖骨小梁结构在轴向切片上的区域差异,该分析方法取整个骨小梁区域的平均值。本研究旨在利用体内高分辨率外周定量 CT(HR-pQCT),描述桡骨远端和胫骨远端横截面上骨小梁结构的空间变异性,以及性别和年龄的影响。本研究共纳入了 146 名年龄在 20-78 岁的健康个体,对其桡骨远端和胫骨远端进行 HR-pQCT 扫描。在整个骨小梁区域(即全局平均值)、内、外以及 8 个定义的子区域中,获得了骨小梁体积分数(BV/TV)、数量(Tb.N)、厚度(Tb.Th)、分离度(Tb.Sp)和异质性(Tb.1/N.SD)等骨小梁参数。研究分析了各区域相对于全局平均值的变化,并比较了女性与男性、青年(20-29 岁)与老年(65-79 岁)个体之间的差异。研究结果显示,桡骨远端和胫骨远端的骨小梁结构存在明显的区域性差异(例如,老年女性桡骨远端的 BV/TV 分别比全局平均值低 40%和高 57%,胫骨远端则分别低 59%和高 100%)。在两个部位,内-外侧(IL)子区域的 BV/TV、Tb.N 和 Tb.Th 较低,Tb.Sp 和 Tb.1/N.SD 也较低;而在桡骨远端的外-前(OA)子区域和胫骨远端的外-内(OM)和外-后(OP)子区域则相反。与其他区域或两个部位的全局平均值相比,内-前(IA)子区域的性别差异最为显著。与年轻人相比,老年人的骨小梁结构主要在桡骨远端的内-后(IP)子区域和胫骨远端的 IL 和 IA 子区域发生变化,而桡骨远端的 OA 子区域和胫骨远端的 OM 子区域则保持不变。综上所述,本研究表明,不仅传统的全局分析可能会掩盖区域差异,而且假设较小子区域的骨状态也可能会引入混淆的抽样误差。因此,结合研究整个区域、每个子区域和皮质骨区域的方法可能会提供更完整的信息。