Hussain Manzoor, Rizvi Syed Adibul Hasan, Askari Hasan, Sultan Gauhar, Lal Murli, Ali Bux, Naqvi Syed Ali Anwar
Department of Urology, Sindh Institute of Urology and Transplantation, Civil Hospital, Karachi, Pakistan.
J Pak Med Assoc. 2009 Dec;59(12):843-6.
To review 17 years experience of the stone clinic with incorporating the changes in practice over the years and to report the benefits of stone clinic in a developing country.
The SIUT Stone clinic was established in 1990 with installation of HM4 Lithotriptor. This clinic is run jointly by a Urologist, Dietitian, Nephrologist, Biochemist and Radiologist. From 1990 - 2007, about 38,749 stone patients received treatment with ESWL (55%), PCNL (6.0%), URS (15.5%), litholopaxy 4.0% and open surgery 19.7%. These patients after treatment were followed in the stone clinic with stone analysis and 24 hours urine metabolic studies where indicated. Dietary and oral hydration programme combined with medical therapy was also instituted. Recurrence rate was noted in those patients who were advised diet modification, oral hydration and medical treatment. Complications of stone disease were documented during the follow-up period.
In ESWL group 8226 patients were followed in the stone clinic for 5 years. In this group, 185 (2.2%) had recurrence of renal calculi. In PCNL group 1306 patients were followed, and 16 (1.1%) had recurrence. In the open surgery group of 1294 patients, 17 (1.3%) had recurrence of renal calculi. The complications of stone disease noted were renal failure and infections in 162 (1.5%) patients, during the follow-up period.
This study shows the beneficial effect of a stone clinic in a developing country and positive effect on the reduction of recurrence and complications of stone disease. Our experience promotes the need to open more specialized stone clinics in areas where stone disease is highly prevalent.
回顾结石门诊17年的经验,结合多年来实践的变化,并报告结石门诊在一个发展中国家的益处。
SIUT结石门诊于1990年随着HM4碎石机的安装而成立。该门诊由一名泌尿科医生、营养师、肾病科医生、生物化学家及放射科医生共同管理。从1990年至2007年,约38749例结石患者接受了体外冲击波碎石术(ESWL,55%)、经皮肾镜取石术(PCNL,6.0%)、输尿管镜检查(URS,15.5%)、碎石术(4.0%)及开放手术(19.7%)治疗。这些患者治疗后在结石门诊接受随访,必要时进行结石分析及24小时尿液代谢研究。还制定了饮食及口服补液方案并结合药物治疗。对那些接受饮食调整、口服补液及药物治疗建议的患者记录其复发率。在随访期间记录结石疾病的并发症。
在ESWL组中,8226例患者在结石门诊随访5年。该组中,185例(2.2%)出现肾结石复发。在PCNL组中,1306例患者接受随访,16例(1.1%)复发。在开放手术组的1294例患者中,17例(1.3%)出现肾结石复发。在随访期间,结石疾病的并发症在162例(1.5%)患者中表现为肾衰竭及感染。
本研究显示了结石门诊在一个发展中国家的有益作用以及对降低结石疾病复发率和并发症的积极作用。我们的经验表明,在结石疾病高发地区有必要开设更多的专业结石门诊。