Ming Jessica M, Lopes Roberto I, Harvey Elizabeth A, Chua Michael E, Saunders Megan A, Matsuda-Abedini Mina, Bägli Darius J, Farhat Walid A, Dos Santos Joana
Division of Urology, The Hospital for Sick Children and Department of Surgery, University of Toronto; Toronto, ON, Canada.
Division of Nephrology, The Hospital for Sick Children and Department of Pediatrics, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Pediatr Qual Saf. 2021 Sep 24;6(5):e474. doi: 10.1097/pq9.0000000000000474. eCollection 2021 Sep-Oct.
Herein, we assess the cost-effectiveness of a multidisciplinary clinic for children with urinary stones. The clinic's primary goals were to decrease unnecessary visits, imaging, and costs while optimizing the quality of care.
Between October 2012 and January 2016, children with complex stone disease, previously treated in urology and/or nephrology clinics, were seen at a triannual pediatric combined stone clinic. We compared the number and cost of ultrasounds, emergency room (ER) visits, and stone surgeries performed before and after each patient's initial evaluation. All patients received satisfaction surveys.
Among the 79 patients, 27 were seen at least twice in the combined clinic and followed multiple times in either urology or nephrology clinics. The mean number of ER visits per patient per year significantly decreased from 0.29 ± 0.36 to 0.10 ± 0.15 ( = 0.002). The mean cost of ER visits went from CAD$ 23.44 ± 28.80 to CAD$ 4.14 ± 12.18 ( = 0.002). Likewise, the mean annual number and cost of stone-related surgeries significantly decreased [(0.38 ± 0.63 versus 0.20 ± 0.32 after the MSC started ( = 0.026) and mean annual cost of surgeries went from CAD$ 182.97 ± 301.49 to CAD$ 41.59 ± 110.97 ( = 0.022)]. Among the survey responses returned, 75% of families believed the clinic was time-saving.
Despite a small sample size, the number of ER visits and stone-related operations significantly decreased after the initial combined clinic intervention. Longer-term data will hopefully confirm if the positive findings continue.
在此,我们评估了一家针对患有尿路结石儿童的多学科诊所的成本效益。该诊所的主要目标是减少不必要的就诊、影像学检查和成本,同时优化护理质量。
在2012年10月至2016年1月期间,患有复杂结石病、此前在泌尿外科和/或肾病科诊所接受过治疗的儿童,每三年在一家儿科联合结石诊所就诊一次。我们比较了每位患者初次评估前后进行超声检查的次数和费用、急诊室就诊次数以及结石手术情况。所有患者均接受了满意度调查。
在79名患者中,有27名患者在联合诊所至少就诊两次,并在泌尿外科或肾病科诊所多次随访。每位患者每年的急诊室就诊平均次数从0.29±0.36显著降至0.10±0.15(P = 0.002)。急诊室就诊的平均费用从23.44加元±28.80加元降至4.14加元±12.18加元(P = 0.002)。同样,与结石相关的手术的年均次数和费用也显著下降[(开始多学科诊所治疗后为0.38±0.63与0.20±0.32,P = 0.026),手术的年均费用从182.97加元±301.49加元降至41.59加元±110.97加元(P = 0.022)]。在回收的调查回复中,75%的家庭认为该诊所节省时间。
尽管样本量较小,但在初次联合诊所干预后,急诊室就诊次数和与结石相关的手术数量显著减少。希望长期数据能证实这些积极结果是否持续。