Department of Radiology, National Defense Medical College, 3-2 Namiki Tokorozawa, Saitama, 359-8513, Japan.
Ann Nucl Med. 2010 May;24(4):319-23. doi: 10.1007/s12149-010-0347-0. Epub 2010 Mar 4.
A questionnaire survey was conducted at all 32 hospitals in Saitama Prefecture to investigate the current difficult situation in terms of nuclear medicine management in the face of the (99m)Tc shortage due to insufficient supply, and 29 hospitals (90.6%) replied.
Of the 29, 15 (51.7%) reported a reduction in the number of nuclear medicine studies performed due to the shortage of supply, although the reduction was small. The decrease per month was less than 20 studies in 73% of the institutions. Of the nuclear medicine studies that involve the use of (99m)Tc, the studies whose reduction in number most seriously affected patient management were, in decreasing order: (99m)Tc-MAA lung perfusion scans, (99m)Tc-MAG(3), (99m)Tc-DTPA, or (99m)Tc-DMSA renoscans, (99m)Tc-MDP bone scans, (99m)Tc-HMPAO or ECD brain SPECT studies, (99m)Tc-MIBI or tetrofosmin myocardial SPECT studies, (99m)Tc-radiocolloid sentinel lymphoscintigraphy, (99m)Tc-HSA-D or pyrophosphate bleeding scans, (99m)Tc-GSA hepatic function reserve scans, and (99m)Tc-MIBI parathyroid scans. The reduction is probably ascribable to factors such as cancellations of emergency studies, absence of substitute studies, sequential studies using the same radiopharmaceutical, and higher cost of the syringe-type products than the vial-type products. Substitutes for (99m)Tc studies were performed at 52% (15/29) of the institutions. Myocardial perfusion imaging with (201)Tl chloride was the most common substitute study.
The results of this survey suggested the several procedures to resolve the issues related to the shortage. The staffs at all institutions except one gave the impression that their nuclear medicine ordering systems had been greatly affected by the shortage of supply. This adverse circumstance, however, may provide a good opportunity to educate the public about nuclear medicine studies that use (99m)Tc and SPECT, with which citizen are now unfamiliar.
在埼玉县的 32 家医院进行了一项问卷调查,以调查由于供应不足导致的(99m)Tc 短缺情况下核医学管理的当前困境,有 29 家医院(90.6%)做出了回应。
在这 29 家医院中,有 15 家(51.7%)报告由于供应短缺而减少了核医学研究的数量,尽管减少的幅度很小。在 73%的机构中,每月减少的数量少于 20 项。在涉及使用(99m)Tc 的核医学研究中,数量减少对患者管理影响最大的研究依次为:(99m)Tc-MAA 肺灌注扫描、(99m)Tc-MAG(3)、(99m)Tc-DTPA 或(99m)Tc-DMSA 肾扫描、(99m)Tc-MDP 骨扫描、(99m)Tc-HMPAO 或 ECD 脑 SPECT 研究、(99m)Tc-MIBI 或 tetrofosmin 心肌 SPECT 研究、(99m)Tc-radiocolloid 前哨淋巴结闪烁显像、(99m)Tc-HSA-D 或焦磷酸盐出血扫描、(99m)Tc-GSA 肝功能储备扫描和(99m)Tc-MIBI 甲状旁腺扫描。减少可能归因于取消急诊研究、缺乏替代研究、使用相同放射性药物进行序贯研究以及注射器型产品比瓶型产品成本更高等因素。有 52%(15/29)的机构进行了(99m)Tc 研究的替代。(201)Tl 氯化物心肌灌注成像是最常见的替代研究。
这项调查的结果提出了一些解决供应短缺相关问题的方法。除一家机构外,所有机构的工作人员都表示,他们的核医学订购系统受到供应短缺的极大影响。这种不利情况可能为核医学研究提供一个很好的机会,让公众了解现在不太熟悉的使用(99m)Tc 和 SPECT 的核医学研究。