基于社区的参与性研究最佳实践的美德伦理学指南。
A virtue ethics guide to best practices for community-based participatory research.
作者信息
Schaffer Marjorie A
机构信息
Bethel University, MN, USA.
出版信息
Prog Community Health Partnersh. 2009 Spring;3(1):83-90. doi: 10.1353/cpr.0.0053.
BACKGROUND
Rule ethics, or principled thinking, is important in the analysis of risks and benefits of research and informed consent, but is not completely adequate for guiding ethical responses to communities as research participants and collaborators. Virtue ethics theory can be used to guide actions in relationships, which are foundational to the implementation of community-based participatory research (CBPR). Virtues are strengths of character that contribute to a life of flourishing or well-being for individuals and communities.
OBJECTIVES
This article provides an overview of virtue ethics theory, identifies common ethical problems in CBPR, and discusses how professional virtues can be used to guide ethical research practice.
METHODS
The virtues of compassion, courage, honesty, humility, justice, and practical reasoning are defined and applied to ethical practice in the development, implementation, and dissemination of CBPR. Best practices for CBPR that consider the well-being of communities are identified.
CONCLUSIONS
The virtues of compassion and humility foster inclusiveness and integration of community perspectives in research collaboration. Courage requires researchers to step out of the research safety-net to listen to community member voices and wisdom and share power in research decisions. Honesty requires researchers to communicate realistic expectations for research outcomes, share all findings with the community, and consider community perspectives in research dissemination. Systematic involvement of the community in all steps of the research process represents the virtue of practical reasoning. From a justice perspective, CBPR aims to restore communities rather than take from them.
背景
规则伦理学,即原则性思维,在分析研究的风险与益处以及知情同意方面很重要,但在指导针对作为研究参与者和合作者的社区做出伦理回应时并不完全适用。美德伦理学理论可用于指导人际关系中的行为,而人际关系是实施基于社区的参与性研究(CBPR)的基础。美德是性格的优势,有助于个人和社区过上繁荣或幸福的生活。
目的
本文概述美德伦理学理论,识别CBPR中常见的伦理问题,并讨论如何运用专业美德来指导符合伦理的研究实践。
方法
界定同情、勇气、诚实、谦逊、正义和实践推理等美德,并将其应用于CBPR的开展、实施和传播中的伦理实践。确定考虑社区福祉的CBPR最佳实践。
结论
同情和谦逊的美德促进在研究合作中纳入并整合社区观点。勇气要求研究人员走出研究的安全网,倾听社区成员的声音和智慧,并在研究决策中分享权力。诚实要求研究人员传达对研究结果的现实期望,与社区分享所有发现,并在研究传播中考虑社区观点。社区系统地参与研究过程的所有步骤体现了实践推理的美德。从正义的角度来看,CBPR旨在恢复社区而非从社区索取。