Govender Vineshree, Panday Mala, Moodley Jagidesa
Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Women's Health and HIV Research Group, Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine, University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, South Africa.
J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2010 Oct;23(10):1151-5. doi: 10.3109/14767051003678002.
An audit of second stage caesarean section (C/S) at a tertiary hospital was undertaken to compare the frequency of perinatal and maternal complications between first and second stage C/S and to evaluate the training level of physicians.
A prospective chart audit of all women who underwent emergency C/S over a 7-month period at a tertiary hospital was conducted. The patients' hospital records were assessed on a daily basis and all relevant information recorded on a structured data sheet categorising demographics, indications for C/S, level of training of decision-maker and surgeon, a consultant's presence, operative complications and neonatal outcome at 5 min post-delivery. The frequency of maternal and neonatal complications was the main outcome measures.
There were 975 first stage and 116 second stage C/S. The commonest causes of second stage C/S were cephalo-pelvic disproportion, prolonged second stage and fetal distress. First stage C/S took a mean time of 35.5 min, while second stage C/S took an average time of 41.6 min to perform (p=0.001). There were 37 and 84 records of complications occurring in first and second stage C/S, respectively.
Maternal complications were significantly higher in second stage C/S while neonatal complications were not significantly different between first and second stage C/S. There was little guidance from consultants at decision-making for second stage C/S.
对一家三级医院的二期剖宫产进行审核,以比较一期和二期剖宫产围产期及产妇并发症的发生率,并评估医生的培训水平。
对一家三级医院7个月内所有接受急诊剖宫产的妇女进行前瞻性病历审核。每天评估患者的医院记录,并将所有相关信息记录在结构化数据表上,对人口统计学、剖宫产指征、决策者和外科医生的培训水平、是否有顾问在场、手术并发症以及出生后5分钟的新生儿结局进行分类。产妇和新生儿并发症的发生率是主要的结局指标。
有975例一期剖宫产和116例二期剖宫产。二期剖宫产最常见的原因是头盆不称、第二产程延长和胎儿窘迫。一期剖宫产平均用时35.5分钟,而二期剖宫产平均用时41.6分钟(p=0.001)。一期和二期剖宫产分别有37例和84例并发症记录。
二期剖宫产产妇并发症明显更高,而一期和二期剖宫产新生儿并发症无显著差异。在二期剖宫产决策时,顾问提供的指导很少。