Anderson Amy, Singh Jasvinder A
Medicine, Minneapolis VA Medical Center and University of Minnesota, One Veterans Drive, Minneapolis, MN, USA, 55417.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2010 Mar 17;2010(3):CD008335. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD008335.pub2.
Pegloticase is a potential new treatment option for patients with chronic gout intolerant to other urate-lowering therapies.
To assess safety (adverse events, death) and efficacy (pain, function, frequency of flares, quality of life, uric acid level, radiographic damage) of pegloticase in various doses or as compared to placebo or other interventions for treatment of hyperuricemia in patients with chronic gout.
We searched six databases: The Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL), via The Cochrane Library, OVID MEDLINE, CINAHL (via EBSCOHost), OVID SPORTdiscus, EMBASE and the Science Citation Index (Web of Science).
All published randomized controlled trials (RCTs) or controlled clinical trials that compared various doses of pegloticase alone or pegloticase alone or in combination with other urate-lowering or anti-inflammatory medications to placebo alone or placebo in combination with these medications, in patients with gout.
Two review authors (AA, JS) independently extracted data from the included trials, including trial and population characteristics, primary and secondary outcomes. For dichotomous and continuous outcomes, we calculated the risk ratio and mean difference, respectively with 95% confidence interval. Major outcomes were: (a)
frequency of gout flares and change in serum uric acid; and (b) safety: adverse events, serious adverse events, withdrawals and death. Minor/secondary outcomes were pain, patient/physician global assessment, tophus burden, health related quality of life, function and radiographic progression.
Only one open-label, phase-II RCT (n=41) met the selection criteria that compared various doses of pegloticase without comparison to placebo or another treatment. Patients were randomized to one of the four doses of pegloticase for 12 to 14 weeks - 4mg every 2 weeks, 8mg every 2 weeks, 8mg every 4 weeks and 12mg every 4 weeks. Percent responders (uric acid below 6 mg/dl 80% or more time) in the four dose groups were 56%, 88%, 52% and 62%. Percent time without hyperuricemia (uric acid below 6 mg/dl) was 78%, 92%, 76% and 76% respectively. No between dose differences were noted. Most common adverse events (10% or more patients) included nephrolithiasis, arthralgia, anemia, dyspnea, headache, muscle spasms, nausea and pyrexia. 89% reported one or more gout flares during the study. Pain, patient/physician global, function, quality of life, tophus size/regression and radiographic progression were not reported in this study.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: There are no published double-blind, placebo-controlled RCTs of pegloticase. More evidence is needed to assess risks/benefits of pegloticase in patients with chronic gout.
聚乙二醇尿酸酶是一种对其他降尿酸疗法不耐受的慢性痛风患者潜在的新治疗选择。
评估不同剂量聚乙二醇尿酸酶或与安慰剂或其他干预措施相比,用于治疗慢性痛风患者高尿酸血症的安全性(不良事件、死亡)和疗效(疼痛、功能、发作频率、生活质量、尿酸水平、影像学损伤)。
我们检索了六个数据库:通过Cochrane图书馆检索Cochrane对照试验中心注册库(CENTRAL)、OVID MEDLINE、CINAHL(通过EBSCOHost)、OVID SPORTdiscus、EMBASE以及科学引文索引(科学网)。
所有已发表的随机对照试验(RCT)或对照临床试验,这些试验比较了单独使用不同剂量的聚乙二醇尿酸酶或聚乙二醇尿酸酶单独使用或与其他降尿酸或抗炎药物联合使用,与单独使用安慰剂或安慰剂与这些药物联合使用,用于痛风患者。
两位综述作者(AA,JS)独立从纳入的试验中提取数据,包括试验和人群特征、主要和次要结局。对于二分法和连续性结局,我们分别计算了风险比和平均差,并给出95%置信区间。主要结局为:(a)疗效:痛风发作频率和血清尿酸变化;(b)安全性:不良事件、严重不良事件、退出试验和死亡情况。次要结局为疼痛、患者/医生整体评估、痛风石负担、健康相关生活质量、功能和影像学进展。
仅有一项开放标签的II期RCT(n = 41)符合选择标准,该试验比较了不同剂量的聚乙二醇尿酸酶,但未与安慰剂或其他治疗进行比较。患者被随机分配到四种剂量的聚乙二醇尿酸酶之一,治疗12至14周——每2周4mg、每2周8mg、每4周8mg和每4周12mg。四个剂量组的反应者百分比(尿酸低于6mg/dl达80%或更多时间)分别为56%、88%、52%和62%。无高尿酸血症(尿酸低于6mg/dl)的时间百分比分别为78%、92%、76%和76%。未观察到剂量之间的差异。最常见的不良事件(10%或更多患者)包括肾结石、关节痛、贫血、呼吸困难、头痛、肌肉痉挛、恶心和发热。89%的患者在研究期间报告了一次或多次痛风发作。本研究未报告疼痛、患者/医生整体评估、功能、生活质量、痛风石大小/消退情况以及影像学进展。
目前尚无已发表的聚乙二醇尿酸酶双盲、安慰剂对照的RCT。需要更多证据来评估聚乙二醇尿酸酶在慢性痛风患者中的风险/获益情况