Attar S, Suter C M, Hankins J R, Sequeira A, McLaughlin J S
Department of Surgery, University of Maryland School of Medicine and Hospital, Baltimore.
Ann Thorac Surg. 1991 May;51(5):711-5; discussion 715-6. doi: 10.1016/0003-4975(91)90110-c.
One hundred nine penetrating cardiac injuries were reviewed: 49 gunshot wounds and 60 stab wounds. They were classified into four groups: group 1 (lifeless), 38; group 2 (agonal), 16; group 3 (shock), 33; and group 4 (stable), 22. Thirty-six patients in group 1 (94%) and 8 of 16 patients in group 2 (50%) underwent emergency room thoracotomy; 24 of 33 in group 3 (73%) and 20 of 22 (90%) underwent thoracotomy in the operating room. Twenty-one (38%) of 55 patients undergoing emergency room thoracotomy survived, whereas 47 (87%) of 54 patients undergoing operating room thoracotomy survived. Survival was 12 of 38 (31%) in group 1, 11 of 16 (69%) in group 2, 26 of 33 (79%) in group 3, and 18 of 22 (82%) in group 4 with an overall survival of 67 of 109 (61%). Gunshot wounds of the heart portend a worse prognosis than stab wounds. Survival of gunshot wounds was 20 of 49 (40%) compared with 47 survivors of 60 stab wounds (78%). Aggressive treatment, including emergency room thoracotomy, is justified for lifeless and deteriorating cardiac injury victims.
回顾了109例穿透性心脏损伤病例:49例枪伤和60例刺伤。它们被分为四组:第1组(无生命体征),38例;第2组(濒死),16例;第3组(休克),33例;第4组(稳定),22例。第1组的36例患者(94%)和第2组的16例患者中的8例(50%)接受了急诊室开胸手术;第3组的33例患者中的24例(73%)和第4组的22例患者中的20例(90%)在手术室接受了开胸手术。接受急诊室开胸手术的55例患者中有21例(38%)存活,而在手术室接受开胸手术的54例患者中有47例(87%)存活。第1组38例患者中有12例(31%)存活,第2组16例患者中有11例(69%)存活,第3组33例患者中有26例(79%)存活,第4组22例患者中有18例(82%)存活,总体存活率为109例中的67例(61%)。心脏枪伤的预后比刺伤更差。枪伤患者的存活率为49例中的20例(40%),而刺伤患者60例中有47例存活(78%)。对于无生命体征和病情恶化的心脏损伤受害者,包括急诊室开胸手术在内的积极治疗是合理的。