Oh V M
Department of Medicine, National University Hospital, Singapore.
Ann Acad Med Singap. 1991 Jan;20(1):31-7.
A placebo may be a pharmacologically active or an inert substance, a procedure, or a patient-doctor interview. Placebos work best in symptoms or disease which vary over time and between patients. The placebo works best in behaviour disorders, somatic autonomic disorders like pain, and neurohumoral disorders like hypertension. However, placebo action is incompletely defined in its molecular pharmacology. The endogenous brain systems of opioid, antiopioid, and gamma-aminobutyric acid polypeptide transmitters and neuronal receptors account in part for placebo analgesia. Non-painful stress may be mediated through other neurohumoral systems. A separate neural system might control these subsystems. Confidence based on the doctor's empathy commonly evokes the placebo effect. How the symbolic input of thought or emotion is translated into neuronal events is unknown. Double-masked 'controlled' clinical trials use placebo to reduce bias; overuse of placebo here may harm some patients. Oral placebos for routine use include thiamine at low dose. Potent drugs like glucocorticoids cannot be justified as placebo in mild disease or non-disease. Both patient and doctor are usually unaware of the placebo effect during interviews. Doctors may increase placebo efficacy by improving interpersonal skills.
安慰剂可以是具有药理活性的物质、惰性物质、一种程序或者一次医患面谈。安慰剂在随时间以及患者个体而变化的症状或疾病中效果最佳。安慰剂在行为障碍、诸如疼痛等躯体自主神经紊乱以及诸如高血压等神经体液紊乱中效果最佳。然而,安慰剂作用在其分子药理学方面尚未完全明确。内源性脑系统中的阿片类、抗阿片类以及γ-氨基丁酸多肽递质和神经元受体在一定程度上解释了安慰剂镇痛作用。非疼痛性应激可能通过其他神经体液系统介导。一个独立的神经系统可能控制这些子系统。基于医生同理心的信心通常会引发安慰剂效应。思想或情感的象征性输入如何转化为神经元事件尚不清楚。双盲“对照”临床试验使用安慰剂以减少偏差;在此过度使用安慰剂可能会伤害一些患者。常规使用的口服安慰剂包括低剂量的硫胺素。在轻度疾病或非疾病状态下,像糖皮质激素这样的强效药物不能作为安慰剂使用。在面谈期间,患者和医生通常都未意识到安慰剂效应。医生可以通过提高人际交往能力来增强安慰剂疗效。