Centre for Youth Mental Health, University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Neurotox Res. 2010 Nov;18(3-4):244-55. doi: 10.1007/s12640-010-9179-x. Epub 2010 Apr 3.
The main mental disorders which develop and persist through adult life typically emerge during the critical developmental phase of adolescence and early adulthood, and are frequently associated with considerable associated distress and functional decline. Our current diagnostic system lacks validity and therapeutic utility, particularly for the early stages of these mental disorders, when symptoms are still evolving and may have not yet stabilised sufficiently to fit familiar or traditional syndromal criteria. Furthermore, there is often difficulty in distinguishing transient developmental or normative changes from the early symptoms of persistent and disabling mental illness. These factors point to the need for reform of our current diagnostic systems. The clinical staging model seeks to define the extent of progression of a disorder at a particular point in time and aims to differentiate early, milder clinical phenomena from those that accompany illness progression and chronicity. The staging framework allows clinicians to select treatments relevant to earlier stages of an illness, and to evaluate their effectiveness in preventing progression and producing remission or return to milder or earlier stages of disorder. For staging to be a valid approach, interventions in the early stages need to shown to be not only more effective but also safer than treatments delivered later in the course of illness. Staging may also allow a more efficient integration of our rapidly expanding knowledge of the biological, social and psychological vulnerability factors involved in development of mental illness into what may ultimately resemble a clinicopathological staging model.
主要的精神障碍会在成年后发展和持续存在,通常在青少年和成年早期的关键发育阶段出现,并且经常与相当大的痛苦和功能下降相关。我们目前的诊断系统缺乏有效性和治疗实用性,特别是对于这些精神障碍的早期阶段,此时症状仍在发展,可能尚未稳定到足以符合熟悉或传统的综合征标准。此外,区分短暂的发育或正常变化与持续和致残性精神疾病的早期症状通常存在困难。这些因素表明需要改革我们目前的诊断系统。临床分期模型旨在定义在特定时间点疾病进展的程度,并旨在区分早期、较轻的临床现象与伴随疾病进展和慢性的现象。分期框架使临床医生能够选择与疾病早期阶段相关的治疗方法,并评估它们在预防进展和产生缓解或恢复到较轻或更早的疾病阶段方面的有效性。为了使分期成为一种有效的方法,早期阶段的干预措施不仅需要更有效,而且需要比在疾病过程中更晚的阶段提供的治疗更安全。分期还可能允许更有效地将我们对涉及精神疾病发展的生物、社会和心理脆弱性因素的快速扩展知识纳入最终可能类似于临床病理分期模型的知识中。