Health Services Research Unit, Kolding Hospital/IRS University of Southern Denmark, Skovvangen 2-8, Kolding 6000, Denmark.
Health Services Research Unit, Kolding Hospital/IRS University of Southern Denmark, Skovvangen 2-8, Kolding 6000, Denmark.
Soc Sci Med. 2010 Jun;70(12):1882-1887. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2010.02.035. Epub 2010 Mar 18.
In order to improve the quality of patient care, questionnaires are often used to identify user's experiences and evaluations, but only a few studies have examined whether measuring user satisfaction at different time points influences the assessment of health care. Several studies have shown equivalency between paper and electronic patient reported outcomes; however, none of these studies have considered the fact that electronic questionnaires are usually completed at the hospital, while paper questionnaires are typically completed at home weeks after the visit. In order to ensure that the comparison of results collected by the two different methods are not biased, the aim of this study was to determine if the interval between an outpatient visit and the assessment of the quality of care influences user satisfaction and to compare response rates between questionnaires completed at different times. In a follow-up study, parents from a paediatric outpatient clinic in Denmark were quasi-randomised to 1 of 3 groups: group 1 completed an electronic questionnaire on a touch screen computer in the outpatient clinic and a paper questionnaire 3-6 weeks after the visit; group 2 completed a paper questionnaire in the outpatient clinic and a paper questionnaire 3-6 weeks after the visit; and group 3 completed a paper questionnaire 3-6 weeks after the visit. A total of 1148 parents completed at least 1 questionnaire. User satisfaction was significantly lower when the assessment was made after a visit to the outpatient clinic compared to an assessment made at the clinic. The response rates of questionnaires completed at the clinic were significantly higher than the response rates of questionnaires completed after the visit. Both the timing of surveys and response rates need to be taken into consideration when planning user surveys. Outcomes from surveys conducted at different times are not readily comparable.
为了提高患者护理质量,常采用问卷调查来识别用户体验和评价,但仅有少数研究检验了在不同时间点测量用户满意度是否会影响对医疗保健的评估。有几项研究表明纸质和电子患者报告结果具有等效性;然而,这些研究均未考虑到电子问卷通常在医院完成,而纸质问卷通常在就诊后数周在家中完成这一事实。为了确保通过两种不同方法收集的结果比较不受偏差影响,本研究旨在确定门诊就诊和护理质量评估之间的间隔是否会影响用户满意度,并比较不同时间完成的问卷的回复率。在一项随访研究中,丹麦儿科门诊的家长被准随机分为 3 组中的 1 组:组 1 在门诊使用触摸屏计算机完成电子问卷,并在就诊后 3-6 周完成纸质问卷;组 2 在门诊完成纸质问卷,并在就诊后 3-6 周完成纸质问卷;组 3 在就诊后 3-6 周完成纸质问卷。共有 1148 位家长至少完成了 1 份问卷。与在诊所评估相比,在就诊后评估时用户满意度显著降低。在诊所完成的问卷的回复率明显高于就诊后完成的问卷的回复率。在规划用户调查时,需要考虑调查时间和回复率。在不同时间进行的调查结果不易比较。