Vandemheen Katherine L, Aaron Shawn D, Poirier Charles, Tullis Elizabeth, O'Connor Annette
Ottawa Health Research Institute, University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
Prog Transplant. 2010 Mar;20(1):81-7. doi: 10.1177/152692481002000113.
Most adults with cystic fibrosis are eventually required to make a decision about referral for lung transplantation.
To identify the decisional needs of these patients and to develop a decision aid to address these needs.
A comprehensive review of the literature, a review of Canadian transplant statistics from 2002 to 2006, and a self-assessment survey of patients who had already made a decision about referral were performed to identify the decisional needs of patients. A decision aid was then developed and evaluated by an expert panel of health care professionals and patients.
Transplant referral patterns vary widely among Canadian cystic fibrosis clinics. Canadian patients with cystic fibrosis who were not residing in transplant centers between 2002 and 2006 were significantly less likely to undergo lung transplants (P < .001). Decisional needs identified by patients included wanting more information on (1) relocation to the transplant center, (2) the benefits and risks of surgery, and (3) how to cope with anxiety and depression when making the decision. In response to these identified needs, a decision aid for lung transplantation was developed. A panel of health care professionals and patients reviewed the decision aid and agreed that the content was appropriate, easy to understand, and unbiased.
The decisional needs of patients with cystic fibrosis who are considering lung transplantation are not being addressed in Canadian cystic fibrosis clinics, especially in clinics outside of transplant centers. An evidence-based decision aid could serve as a useful tool to help address these needs.
大多数成年囊性纤维化患者最终都需要做出关于转诊进行肺移植的决定。
确定这些患者的决策需求,并开发一种决策辅助工具来满足这些需求。
对文献进行全面综述,回顾2002年至2006年加拿大的移植统计数据,并对已经做出转诊决定的患者进行自我评估调查,以确定患者的决策需求。然后由医疗保健专业人员和患者组成的专家小组开发并评估了一种决策辅助工具。
加拿大各囊性纤维化诊所之间的移植转诊模式差异很大。2002年至2006年期间不住在移植中心的加拿大囊性纤维化患者接受肺移植的可能性明显较低(P < .001)。患者确定的决策需求包括希望获得更多关于(1)搬到移植中心、(2)手术的益处和风险以及(3)在做决定时如何应对焦虑和抑郁的信息。针对这些已确定的需求,开发了一种肺移植决策辅助工具。一个由医疗保健专业人员和患者组成的小组对该决策辅助工具进行了审查,并一致认为其内容合适、易于理解且无偏见。
加拿大囊性纤维化诊所,尤其是移植中心以外的诊所,没有满足考虑进行肺移植的囊性纤维化患者的决策需求。一种基于证据的决策辅助工具可以作为满足这些需求的有用工具。