Unz Foundation, PO BOX 9023, Berkeley, CA 94707, United States.
Med Hypotheses. 2010 Oct;75(4):363-7. doi: 10.1016/j.mehy.2010.03.033. Epub 2010 Apr 20.
There are several hypotheses which explain the de-pigmentation of humans. The most prominent environmental explanation is that reduced endogenous vitamin D production due to diminished radiation at higher latitudes had a deleterious impact on fitness. This drove de-pigmentation as an adaptive response. A model of natural selection explains the high correlations found between low vitamin D levels and ill health, as vitamin D's role in immune response has clear evolutionary implications. But recent genomic techniques have highlighted the likelihood that extreme de-pigmentation in Eurasia is a feature of the last 10,000years, not the Upper Pleistocene, when modern humans first settled northern Eurasia. Additionally the data imply two independent selection events in eastern and western Eurasia. Therefore new parameters must be added to the model of natural selection so as to explain the relatively recent and parallel adaptive responses. I propose a model of gene-culture co-evolution whereby the spread of agriculture both reduced dietary vitamin D sources and led to more powerful selection on immune response because of the rise of infectious diseases with greater population densities. This model explains the persistence of relatively dark-skinned peoples at relatively high latitudes and the existence of relatively light-skinned populations at low latitudes. It also reinforces the importance of vitamin D as a micronutrient because of the evidence of extremely powerful fitness implications in the recent human past of pigmentation.
有几种假说可以解释人类的色素减退现象。最突出的环境解释是,由于高纬度地区辐射减少,内源性维生素 D 生成减少,对健康产生了有害影响。这促使色素减退成为一种适应性反应。自然选择模型解释了维生素 D 水平低与健康状况不佳之间存在高度相关性的原因,因为维生素 D 在免疫反应中的作用具有明显的进化意义。但最近的基因组技术强调了欧亚地区极度色素减退很可能是过去 10000 年的特征,而不是在上更新世,当时现代人类首次在北欧亚定居。此外,这些数据表明,在欧亚东部和西部发生了两次独立的选择事件。因此,必须向自然选择模型添加新的参数,以解释相对较近和并行的适应性反应。我提出了一个基因-文化共同进化的模型,该模型认为农业的传播减少了饮食中维生素 D 的来源,并由于人口密度增加导致传染病增多,从而对免疫反应产生了更强大的选择压力。该模型解释了相对较深肤色的人群在相对高纬度地区的存在,以及相对浅肤色的人群在低纬度地区的存在。它还强调了维生素 D 作为一种微量营养素的重要性,因为在人类最近的色素沉着历史中,有证据表明其对健康有极强的影响。