Mark A, Granström M
Division of Child Health, Landstingets kansli, Jönköping, Sweden.
Eur J Epidemiol. 1991 Mar;7(2):121-6. doi: 10.1007/BF00237354.
The cumulative incidence of pertussis at six years of age in the first unvaccinated cohort after cessation of immunisation in Sweden was investigated by serological methods and by a validation of the national epidemiological surveillance system by reports from the Child Health Centres (CHCs). In 312/385 (81%) eligible children, both an interview with the parents and a blood sample from the child could be obtained. The CHC reports yielded a cumulative incidence of 31%, whereas the serological assays found 54%. Of the cases reported by the parents to the CHCs, 89% were seropositives. In the additional cases of pertussis reported at the study interview, only 61% could be confirmed (p less than 0.001). Among children with reported severe cough not suspected to be pertussis, 46% were seropositive, distributed as 33% seropositives in cases with cough duration of less than 4 weeks and 69% for longer coughs (p less than 0.01). In the CHC reports, the parental diagnosis was found to have been confirmed in three-quarters of cases by medical personnel. The CHC reporting system was thus found to be reliable with an observed specificity of 93%, but sensitivity of only 52%. Thus, even this surveillance system, which yields the highest incidence rates, underestimates the incidence of the disease.
通过血清学方法以及利用儿童健康中心(CHC)的报告对瑞典免疫接种停止后首个未接种疫苗队列中6岁儿童百日咳的累积发病率进行了调查,并对国家流行病学监测系统进行了验证。在385名符合条件的儿童中,有312名(81%)儿童接受了家长访谈并采集了血样。儿童健康中心的报告显示累积发病率为31%,而血清学检测发现的发病率为54%。家长向儿童健康中心报告的病例中,89%为血清学阳性。在研究访谈中报告的额外百日咳病例中,只有61%能够得到确认(p<0.001)。在报告有严重咳嗽但不怀疑是百日咳的儿童中,46%为血清学阳性,咳嗽持续时间少于4周的病例中血清学阳性率为33%,咳嗽时间较长的病例中血清学阳性率为69%(p<0.01)。在儿童健康中心的报告中,发现四分之三病例的家长诊断得到了医务人员的确认。因此,发现儿童健康中心报告系统是可靠的,观察到的特异性为93%,但灵敏度仅为52%。因此,即使是这个产生最高发病率的监测系统,也低估了该疾病的发病率。