University of Bielefeld, Department of Animal Ecology, Morgenbreede 45, 33615 Bielefeld, Germany.
Aquat Toxicol. 2010 Aug 15;99(2):126-37. doi: 10.1016/j.aquatox.2010.04.008. Epub 2010 Apr 24.
Ivermectin is a widely applied veterinary pharmaceutical that is highly toxic to several non-target organisms. So far, little is known about its impact on benthic freshwater species, although its rapid sorption to sediment particles and high persistence in aquatic sediments have raised concerns about the risk for benthic organisms. In the present study, indoor microcosms were used to assess the impact of ivermectin on freshwater meiobenthic communities over a period of 224 days. Microcosm sediments were directly spiked with ivermectin to achieve nominal concentrations of 0.9, 9, and 45 microg kg(-1) dw. Initially measured ivermectin concentrations (day 0) were 0.6, 6.2, and 31 microg kg(-1) dw. In addition to abundance of major meiobenthic organism groups, the nematode community was assessed on the species level, assuming a high risk for free-living nematodes due to their close phylogenetic relationship to the main target organisms of ivermectin, parasitic nematodes. Benthic microcrustaceans (cladocerans, ostracods) and nematodes showed the most sensitive response to ivermectin, while tardigrades profited from the presence of the pharmaceutical. The most pronounced effects on the meiofauna community composition occurred at the highest treatment level (31 microg kg(-1) dw), leading to a no observed effect concentration (NOEC(Community)) of 6.2 microg kg(-1) dw. However, the nematode community was already seriously affected at a concentration of 6.2 microg kg(-1) dw with two bacterivorous genera, Monhystera and Eumonhystera, being the most sensitive, whereas species of omnivorous genera (Tripyla, Tobrilus) increased in abundance after the application of ivermectin. Thus, a NOEC(Community) of 0.6 microg kg(-1) dw was derived for nematodes. Direct and indirect effects of ivermectin on meiobenthic communities could be demonstrated. The pharmaceutical is likely to pose a high risk, because its NOECs are close to predicted environmental concentrations (PECs) in sediments (0.45-2.17 microg kg(-1) dw), resulting in worst case risk quotients (RQs) of 1.05-36.2. This observation lends support to efforts aimed at preventing the repeated entry of ivermectin in aquatic environments and thus its accumulation in sediments. Moreover, this study points out that model ecosystem studies should be part of environmental risk assessments (ERAs) of veterinary medicinal products (VMPs).
伊维菌素是一种广泛应用于兽医领域的药物,对许多非目标生物具有高度毒性。尽管伊维菌素迅速被沉积物颗粒吸附并在水生生境中高度持久,这引发了对底栖生物风险的担忧,但目前人们对其对底栖淡水物种的影响知之甚少。本研究采用室内微宇宙方法,在 224 天内评估了伊维菌素对淡水小型底栖生物群落的影响。微宇宙沉积物直接用伊维菌素进行喷洒,以实现 0.9、9 和 45μgkg-1(干重)的名义浓度。最初测量的伊维菌素浓度(第 0 天)为 0.6、6.2 和 31μgkg-1(干重)。除了主要小型底栖生物类群的丰度外,还在物种水平上评估了线虫群落,因为自由生活的线虫与伊维菌素的主要靶标生物,寄生线虫密切相关,因此假定它们面临高风险。底栖微型甲壳类动物(桡足类、介形类)和线虫对线虫菌素的反应最为敏感,而缓步动物则从药物的存在中受益。在最高处理水平(31μgkg-1)下,对小型底栖动物群落组成的影响最为明显,导致未观察到的效应浓度(群落)为 6.2μgkg-1。然而,在 6.2μgkg-1的浓度下,线虫群落已经受到严重影响,其中两个食细菌属,Monhystera 和 Eumonhystera 最为敏感,而杂食性属(Tripyla、Tobrilus)的物种在伊维菌素施用后丰度增加。因此,线虫的未观察到效应浓度(群落)为 0.6μgkg-1。可以证明伊维菌素对小型底栖生物群落的直接和间接影响。该药物很可能构成高风险,因为其未观察到的效应浓度接近沉积物中的预测环境浓度(0.45-2.17μgkg-1),导致最坏情况风险比率(RQ)为 1.05-36.2。这一观察结果支持了旨在防止伊维菌素反复进入水生环境并因此在沉积物中积累的努力。此外,本研究指出,模型生态系统研究应成为兽医药品(VMP)环境风险评估(ERA)的一部分。