Natanzon Iris, Szecsenyi Joachim, Ose Dominik, Joos Stefanie
University Hospital of Heidelberg, Department of General Practice and Health Services Research, Heidelberg, Germany.
Rural Remote Health. 2010 Apr-Jun;10(2):1347. Epub 2010 May 7.
There is a shortage of general practitioners (GPs) in many countries, especially in rural areas. There are several reasons for this shortage. Over the last decade, fewer medical students in Germany have decided to work in patient care, even fewer in general practice and fewer still in general practice in rural areas. The aim of this study was to explore the 'pros and cons' of GPs' work in rural areas and to identify from GPs' perspective possible measures for counteracting future GP shortages.
Within a qualitative approach, 16 semi-structured interviews were conducted with GPs. Data analysis was carried out using qualitative content analysis.
The results were categorized into three main inductively-derived categories: personal, professional and regional/structural level. A higher level of self-confidence and a higher 'feel-good' factor due to GPs originating from rural areas were positive aspects at the personal level. Regarding the professional level, a low level of competition and varied work made a GP's profession attractive in rural areas. Negative aspects were mostly apparent at the regional/structural level, such a low earnings and few leisure facilities. Measures to counter the lack of GPs in rural areas were explored on all three levels: on the personal level, more optimism and resulting satisfaction on the part of doctors in rural areas could be improved by enhancing the benefits of being a doctor in a rural area. Regarding the professional level, more group practices are required to make working as a GP in a rural area more attractive. At a regional/structural level, young physicians who originate from rural areas should be recruited to work in rural areas.
Financial incentives are regarded as not sufficient to attract enough young physicians to open practices in rural areas. Future action will be required at the personal, professional and regional/structural levels. The origin of medical students (urban or rural) should be considered a relevant predicting factor for recruitment.
许多国家,尤其是农村地区,全科医生短缺。造成这种短缺的原因有几个。在过去十年中,德国选择从事患者护理工作的医学生减少,选择从事全科医疗工作的更少,而选择在农村地区从事全科医疗工作的则更少。本研究的目的是探讨全科医生在农村地区工作的“利弊”,并从全科医生的角度确定应对未来全科医生短缺的可能措施。
采用定性研究方法,对16名全科医生进行了半结构化访谈。采用定性内容分析法进行数据分析。
结果归纳为三个主要类别:个人层面、专业层面和区域/结构层面。由于全科医生来自农村地区,个人层面的积极方面包括更强的自信心和更高的“感觉良好”因素。在专业层面,竞争程度低和工作多样使农村地区的全科医生职业颇具吸引力。负面因素大多出现在区域/结构层面,如收入低和休闲设施少。在所有三个层面探讨了应对农村地区全科医生短缺的措施:在个人层面,通过增加在农村地区当医生的好处,可以提高农村地区医生的乐观情绪和满意度。在专业层面,需要更多的联合执业,以使在农村地区从事全科医生工作更具吸引力。在区域/结构层面,应招募来自农村地区的年轻医生到农村地区工作。
经济激励措施被认为不足以吸引足够多的年轻医生到农村地区开业。未来需要在个人、专业和区域/结构层面采取行动。医学生的出身(城市或农村)应被视为招聘的一个相关预测因素。