Pohontsch Nadine J, Hansen Heike, Schäfer Ingmar, Scherer Martin
Department of Primary Medical Care, University Medical Centre Hamburg-Eppendorf, Hamburg, Germany.
Fam Pract. 2018 Mar 27;35(2):209-215. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmx083.
Inadequate recruitment numbers for GPs in rural regions give cause for concern. Working in rural regions is less attractive among medical students because of strong associations concerning a higher workload, restriction of privacy and demands exceeding their competences. We aimed to explore perceptions of GPs working in urban versus rural regions to contrast these prejudices.
We conducted nine focus groups with GPs [female = 21, male = 44] from urban and rural regions, using a semi-structured guideline. Transcripts were content analyzed using deductive and inductive categories.
Urban GPs perceived themselves as a provider of medical services and rural GPs as being a medical companion. Compared to urban GPs, GPs from non-urban regions portray themselves more strongly as a family physician that accompanies patients 'from the cradle to the grave' and is responsible for the treatment of any medical issue. They emphasized their close relationship with their patients. Rural GPs establish a close relationship with their patients and considered this as beneficial for the treatment relationship. This aspect seems to play a subordinate role for urban GPs.
GPs enjoy their work and the role they play in their patients' lives. Being a rural GP was described very positively. Greater emphasis should be made on positive aspects of being a GP in rural regions, e.g. by university lectures given by rural GPs, campaigns emphasizing the positive aspects of working as a GP [in rural regions], promotion of work placements or incentives for working in rural general practices.
农村地区全科医生招募人数不足令人担忧。由于普遍认为农村工作负担更重、隐私受限且要求超出其能力范围,医学生对在农村地区工作兴趣较低。我们旨在探究城市和农村地区全科医生的看法,以对比这些偏见。
我们使用半结构化指南,对来自城市和农村地区的全科医生[女性=21名,男性=44名]进行了9次焦点小组访谈。对访谈记录进行了演绎和归纳分类的内容分析。
城市全科医生将自己视为医疗服务提供者,而农村全科医生则认为自己是医疗伙伴。与城市全科医生相比,非城市地区的全科医生更强烈地将自己描绘为陪伴患者“从摇篮到坟墓”的家庭医生,并负责治疗任何医疗问题。他们强调与患者的密切关系。农村全科医生与患者建立了密切关系,并认为这对治疗关系有益。这方面对城市全科医生来说似乎作用较小。
全科医生享受他们的工作以及他们在患者生活中所扮演的角色。农村全科医生的工作被描述得非常积极。应更加强调农村地区全科医生工作的积极方面,例如由农村全科医生进行大学讲座、开展强调(农村地区)全科医生工作积极方面的活动、推广实习机会或为在农村全科医疗工作提供激励措施。