Hassan Zaheed, Mullins Robert F, Friedman Bruce C, Shaver Joseph R, Brandigi Claus, Alam Badrul, Mian Mohammad A H
Joseph M Still Burn Centers, Inc., Augusta, Georgia, USA.
Undersea Hyperb Med. 2010 Mar-Apr;37(2):115-23.
There is not enough clinical data to support the benefit of adjuvant HBO2 therapy for necrotizing fasciitis (NF). We retrospectively reviewed our 67 NF cases to compare the outcomes of adjuvant HBO2 therapy versus non-HBO2 therapy. The overall outcome and morbidity criteria were compared between a group of 29 NF patients who received the adjuvant HBO2 and a group of the remaining 38 NF patients treated by only surgery and other standards of care. This study did not find any difference between the groups in average length of hospital stay, and their mortality. However, six (25%) of the non-HBO2 group patients required amputation of extremities compared to one of the HBO2 group (Fisher exact p = 0.09). Although the benefit of adjuvant HBO2 therapy remains controversial for NF, and the outcomes of this study are not statistically significant, there is a trend in clinical outcomes which shows that the therapy has the potential to reduce the number of amputation and salvage extremities. These findings necessitate multicenter, prospective, case control study to assess the possible benefit of adjuvant HBO2 therapy for NF.
目前尚无足够的临床数据支持高压氧(HBO2)辅助治疗坏死性筋膜炎(NF)的益处。我们回顾性分析了67例NF病例,以比较HBO2辅助治疗与非HBO2治疗的结果。在一组接受HBO2辅助治疗的29例NF患者和另一组仅接受手术及其他标准治疗的38例NF患者之间,比较了总体结果和发病率标准。本研究未发现两组在平均住院时间和死亡率方面存在差异。然而,非HBO2组中有6例(25%)患者需要截肢,而HBO2组中只有1例(Fisher精确检验p = 0.09)。尽管HBO2辅助治疗对NF的益处仍存在争议,且本研究结果无统计学意义,但临床结果存在一种趋势,表明该治疗有可能减少截肢数量并挽救肢体。这些发现需要进行多中心、前瞻性、病例对照研究,以评估HBO2辅助治疗对NF的潜在益处。