Ludlow Christy L
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, James Madison University, Harrisonburg, Virginia 22807, USA.
Curr Opin Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2010 Jun;18(3):159-64. doi: 10.1097/MOO.0b013e3283395dec.
To assess current information regarding the physiological effects of transcutaneous electrical stimulation (TES) on the neck and current evidence regarding the clinical effects of adding TES to dysphagia rehabilitation.
Physiological studies have demonstrated that when electrical stimulation is applied on the throat it will lower the hyo-laryngeal complex and resist elevation needed for airway protection during swallowing. Submental TES has not been found to effectively elevate the hyo-laryngeal complex. Recent controlled clinical trials have had mixed results. Most indicate that TES is beneficial in the treatment of dysphagia; however, studies differ on whether these effects are greater than, equal to, or less than traditional therapy alone for the rehabilitation of swallowing.
Currently TES for dysphagia is one of several tools available to the clinician for the rehabilitation of dysphagia. The two controlled clinical trials demonstrate that use of TES in dysphagia therapy is equivalent to traditional dysphagia therapy and of greater benefit only on one of several measures in one study. TES should be used only in patients who can overcome the resistive lowering of the hyo-laryngeal complex induced by TES which could place severely affected patients at greater risk of penetration.
评估有关经皮电刺激(TES)对颈部生理影响的当前信息,以及关于在吞咽困难康复中添加TES的临床效果的现有证据。
生理学研究表明,当在喉部施加电刺激时,会降低舌骨-喉复合体,并阻碍吞咽时气道保护所需的抬高动作。尚未发现颏下TES能有效抬高舌骨-喉复合体。近期的对照临床试验结果不一。大多数研究表明,TES对吞咽困难的治疗有益;然而,对于这些效果在吞咽康复方面是否大于、等于或小于单纯传统疗法,各研究存在差异。
目前,用于吞咽困难的TES是临床医生可用于吞咽困难康复的几种工具之一。两项对照临床试验表明,在吞咽困难治疗中使用TES等同于传统吞咽困难治疗,且仅在一项研究的若干指标中的一项上有更大益处。TES仅应在能够克服由TES引起的舌骨-喉复合体抵抗性下降的患者中使用,因为这可能使严重受影响的患者发生误吸的风险更高。