Plochocki Jeffrey H
Department of Anatomy, Midwestern University, Glendale, AZ 85308, USA.
J Forensic Sci. 2011 Jan;56(1):161-4. doi: 10.1111/j.1556-4029.2010.01455.x.
This study assesses the predictive value of anterior sacral curvature for sex estimation from skeletonized remains. Sacra from a sample of 125 American adults of known age and sex were examined. Nine measurements describing anterior sacral curvature were used in the analysis. Statistical treatment of the data included univariate statistics and discriminant function analysis for sex classification. A bootstrap validation method was employed to assess the classification error rates. Sacral curvature was significantly greater in men than in women at the level of the S2-S3 and S3-S4 articulations (p<0.05). Correct classification estimates for the discriminant function range from 66-72%. Although sexually dimorphic, metric observations of sacral curvature are not as reliable at predicting sex as other skeletal elements. Anterior sacral curvature should only be used for sex estimation in the absence of other, more reliable, indicators.
本研究评估了骶骨前曲度在从骨骼残骸进行性别估计中的预测价值。对125名已知年龄和性别的美国成年人样本的骶骨进行了检查。分析中使用了九项描述骶骨前曲度的测量指标。数据的统计处理包括单变量统计和用于性别分类的判别函数分析。采用自助验证方法评估分类错误率。在S2-S3和S3-S4关节水平,男性的骶骨曲度明显大于女性(p<0.05)。判别函数的正确分类估计范围为66%-72%。尽管骶骨曲度存在性别差异,但与其他骨骼元素相比,其测量观察在预测性别方面并不那么可靠。只有在没有其他更可靠指标的情况下,才应使用骶骨前曲度进行性别估计。