Nenkov R, Radev R, Madzhov R
Khirurgiia (Sofiia). 2009(1):24-7.
Various new, minimally invasive techniques, using endoscopic, video-assisted and non-endoscopic, open access have recently appeared in the surgical treatment of nodular thyroid disease. Aim of this study is to examine the feasibility, indications and efficacy of the minimally invasive open approach (MOATS) in the thyroid surgery.
395 patients (368 (93.2%) females and 27 (6.8%) males, age 17 to 65 years with size of the dominant thyroid nodule less than 3.5 cm have been operated on in our institution over a four years period, using minimally invasive open access thyroid surgery. Preoperative ultrasound examination of the thyroid gland was performed in all patients and FNAB--in 121 (30.6%) of the cases. Central cervical access has been used in all patients. The surgical incision size has been measured in the beginning and at the end of the procedure, on the fourth day and when the sutures have been removed.
Partial thyroid resection of one or both thyroid lobes has been performed in 59, respectively in 17 patients; subtotal lobar resection in 106 patients; lobectomy--in 111 patients; lobectomy with partial or subtotal resection of the opposite lobe--in 34, respectively 15 patients; subtotal bilateral thyroid resection--in 25 patients and thyroidectomy in 28 patients. Pathological examination revealed nodular goiter in 168 patients (solitary variant in 99 and multinodular--in 69 patients); toxic nodular goiter--in 13 patients; follicular adenoma--in 175 patients; Hashimoto thyroiditis--in 11 and thyroid carcinoma--in 28 patients. Main peri- and postoperative parameters have been compared with those of a group of patients (well matched by sex, age, nodule size and pathological findings) in witch conventional approach has been used. Minimal collar incision and scar, possibility to apply any extent of surgery witch may be necessary, comparable operative time with the conventional method and good cosmetic results are the undoubtedly good advantages of the technique.
Our experience demonstrates that the minimally invasive open access in the thyroid surgery is a simple, safe and effective surgical technique, with very satisfactory cosmetic results in properly selected patients with small to middle-size thyroid nodules. The technique combines the advantages of an endoscopic resection with those of the conventional, classic technique.
最近,各种新的微创技术,包括内镜、视频辅助以及非内镜的开放入路,已出现在结节性甲状腺疾病的外科治疗中。本研究的目的是探讨微创开放入路(MOATS)在甲状腺手术中的可行性、适应证和疗效。
在四年时间里,我们机构对395例患者(368例(93.2%)女性和27例(6.8%)男性,年龄17至65岁,优势甲状腺结节大小小于3.5厘米)采用微创开放入路甲状腺手术进行了手术。所有患者均进行了术前甲状腺超声检查,121例(30.6%)患者进行了细针穿刺活检(FNAB)。所有患者均采用颈部中央入路。在手术开始和结束时、第四天以及拆线时测量手术切口大小。
分别对59例和17例患者进行了一侧或双侧甲状腺叶部分切除术;106例患者进行了次全叶切除术;111例患者进行了叶切除术;34例和15例患者分别进行了对侧叶部分或次全切除的叶切除术;25例患者进行了双侧甲状腺次全切除术,28例患者进行了甲状腺全切除术。病理检查显示,168例患者为结节性甲状腺肿(99例为单发,69例为多发);13例患者为毒性结节性甲状腺肿;175例患者为滤泡性腺瘤;11例患者为桥本甲状腺炎;28例患者为甲状腺癌。将主要围手术期和术后参数与一组采用传统手术方法(在性别、年龄、结节大小和病理结果方面匹配良好)的患者进行了比较。最小的领口切口和疤痕、能够进行任何必要程度的手术、与传统方法相当的手术时间以及良好的美容效果无疑是该技术的优点。
我们的经验表明,甲状腺手术中的微创开放入路是一种简单、安全且有效的手术技术,对于适当选择的中小尺寸甲状腺结节患者,美容效果非常令人满意。该技术结合了内镜切除术和传统经典技术的优点。