Aagaard E, Donslund C, Wenzel A, Sewerin I
Department of Radiology, Royal Dental College, Aarhus, Denmark.
Scand J Dent Res. 1991 Apr;99(2):166-72. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0722.1991.tb01880.x.
The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect on subtraction image quality of number of a) gray shades sampled during camera recording, and b) reference points positioned in the two images to be subtracted. Intraoral radiographs were obtained in each of 12 patients, one at 0 degrees and one at 15 degrees horizontal angulation in a standardized recording procedure. The radiographs were videorecorded twice sampling 1) 160-180 and 2) 200-220 shades of gray. The 0 degrees radiographic image was digitally copied. Subtractions were performed between the identical (0 degrees/0 degrees) and the non-identical (0 degrees/15 degrees) radiographs from both gray shade samples after positioning 5, 10, 15, and 20 reference points, respectively, in each of the images to be subtracted. The standard deviation in the subtraction image histogram was used as the test parameter for image quality. No differences existed between image quality obtained from the radiographs sampled using 160-180 and 200-220 shades of gray (P greater than 0.05). The standard deviation fell continuously, the more reference points were positioned in the images. For the 0 degrees/0 degrees images the difference was statistically significant between the 5 and 10 point images (P = 0.045) while for the 0 degrees/15 degrees images differences existed between 5 and 10 point images (P = 0.077) and the 10 and 15 point images (P = 0.048). The precision of reference point positioning as evaluated in the two identical images was satisfactory, the divergence being on average 1.4 pixels.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
a)相机记录过程中采样的灰度级数,以及b)在要相减的两幅图像中定位的参考点数量。采用标准化记录程序,为12例患者分别获取口腔内X线片,一张水平角度为0度,另一张为15度。对X线片进行两次视频记录,分别采样1)160 - 180级灰度和2)200 - 220级灰度。将0度的X线图像进行数字复制。在要相减的每幅图像中分别定位5、10、15和20个参考点后,对来自两个灰度样本的相同(0度/0度)和不同(0度/15度)X线片进行减影。减影图像直方图的标准差用作图像质量的测试参数。使用160 - 180级灰度和200 - 220级灰度采样的X线片所获得的图像质量之间无差异(P大于0.05)。图像中定位的参考点越多,标准差持续下降。对于0度/0度图像,5点图像和10点图像之间差异具有统计学意义(P = 0.045),而对于0度/15度图像,5点图像和10点图像之间(P = 0.077)以及10点图像和15点图像之间(P = 0.048)存在差异。在两幅相同图像中评估的参考点定位精度令人满意,平均偏差为1.4像素。(摘要截断于250字)