Kirshner Lewis A
Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, Cambridge, MA 02139, USA.
J Am Psychoanal Assoc. 2010 Apr;58(2):327-45. doi: 10.1177/0003065110368859.
The work of Arnold Modell over the past forty years constitutes a major contribution to contemporary psychoanalytic thought. Of particular note are his efforts to sustain a paradoxical conception of the self as both an evolving, contingent product and an enduring core. Moving back and forth between celebration of the private self and articulation of the impossibility of a one-person psychoanalysis, Modell's quest to define the nature of the self has taken him from classical analytic theory, through Winnicott and object relations, to the philosophy of intersubjectivity and, in later years, to the work of infant researchers and neuroscientists. In doing so, he has placed the continuity of the self and the making of personal meaning at the center of psychoanalytic practice. The evolution of his thinking reflects a turn toward a protean and transitional conception of the self, away from the notion of an enduring or superordinate core self.
阿诺德·莫德尔在过去四十年间的工作对当代精神分析思想做出了重大贡献。特别值得一提的是,他致力于维持一种关于自我的矛盾观念,即自我既是一个不断演变、偶然产生的产物,又是一个持久的核心。莫德尔在对私密自我的颂扬与对一人精神分析之不可能性的阐述之间来回穿梭,他对自我本质的探寻引领他从经典分析理论出发,历经温尼科特和客体关系理论,走向主体间性哲学,在晚年又涉足婴儿研究者和神经科学家的研究领域。通过这样的历程,他将自我的连续性和个人意义的构建置于精神分析实践的核心位置。他思想的演变反映出一种向自我的多变性和过渡性观念的转变,背离了持久或至高无上的核心自我概念。